Summary random effects estimates by screening procedure
| Procedure . | n* . | . | PPV (95% CI) . | Se (95% CI) . | Sp (95% CI) . | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mammogram | 19 | Fixed† | 79 (77-80) | 93 (92-94) | 62 (60-64) | |
| Random‡ | 79 (74-84) | 95 (93-97) | 61 (54-68) | |||
| Filled§ | 92 (88-95) | |||||
| CBE | 7 | Fixed | 78 (76-80) | 93 (92-95) | 29 (25-33) | |
| Random | 82 (73-88) | 94 (91-96) | 26 (18-36) | |||
| Filled | 76 (65-84) | 92 (88-95) | ||||
| Pap smear | 26 | Fixed | 70 (69-72) | 91 (90-92) | 47 (45-49) | |
| Random | 76 (69-81) | 93 (91-95) | 48 (40-57) | |||
| Filled | 68 (61-74) | 88 (83-91) | ||||
| PSA test | 6 | Fixed | 76 (73-79) | 71 (68-74) | 73 (70-76) | |
| Random | 79 (71-85) | 71 (68-74) | 73 (62-81) | |||
| Filled | ||||||
| DRE | 10 | Fixed | 63 (61-65) | 74 (71-76) | 60 (58-62) | |
| Random | 59 (52-66) | 75 (66-82) | 60 (55-66) | |||
| Filled | 67 (59-74) | |||||
| FOBT | 13 | Fixed | 62 (60-64) | 78 (76-80) | 77 (76-79) | |
| Random | 62 (50-73) | 82 (73-88) | 78 (71-83) | |||
| Filled | ||||||
| Screening endoscopy | 13 | Fixed | 56 (54-59) | 82 (80-84) | 85 (84-86) | |
| Random | 51 (41-62) | 79 (73-84) | 90 (85-93) | |||
| Filled | 83 (77-88) | 83 (77-88) | ||||
| Procedure . | n* . | . | PPV (95% CI) . | Se (95% CI) . | Sp (95% CI) . | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mammogram | 19 | Fixed† | 79 (77-80) | 93 (92-94) | 62 (60-64) | |
| Random‡ | 79 (74-84) | 95 (93-97) | 61 (54-68) | |||
| Filled§ | 92 (88-95) | |||||
| CBE | 7 | Fixed | 78 (76-80) | 93 (92-95) | 29 (25-33) | |
| Random | 82 (73-88) | 94 (91-96) | 26 (18-36) | |||
| Filled | 76 (65-84) | 92 (88-95) | ||||
| Pap smear | 26 | Fixed | 70 (69-72) | 91 (90-92) | 47 (45-49) | |
| Random | 76 (69-81) | 93 (91-95) | 48 (40-57) | |||
| Filled | 68 (61-74) | 88 (83-91) | ||||
| PSA test | 6 | Fixed | 76 (73-79) | 71 (68-74) | 73 (70-76) | |
| Random | 79 (71-85) | 71 (68-74) | 73 (62-81) | |||
| Filled | ||||||
| DRE | 10 | Fixed | 63 (61-65) | 74 (71-76) | 60 (58-62) | |
| Random | 59 (52-66) | 75 (66-82) | 60 (55-66) | |||
| Filled | 67 (59-74) | |||||
| FOBT | 13 | Fixed | 62 (60-64) | 78 (76-80) | 77 (76-79) | |
| Random | 62 (50-73) | 82 (73-88) | 78 (71-83) | |||
| Filled | ||||||
| Screening endoscopy | 13 | Fixed | 56 (54-59) | 82 (80-84) | 85 (84-86) | |
| Random | 51 (41-62) | 79 (73-84) | 90 (85-93) | |||
| Filled | 83 (77-88) | 83 (77-88) | ||||