In chronic infections and in cancer, persistent antigen stimulation under suboptimal conditions can lead to the induction of T-cell exhaustion. Exhausted T cells are characterized by an increased expression of inhibitory markers and a progressive and hierarchical loss of function. Although cancer-induced exhaustion in CD8 T cells has been well-characterized and identified as a therapeutic target (i.e., via checkpoint inhibition), in-depth analyses of exhaustion in other immune cell types, including CD4 T cells, is wanting. While perhaps attributable to the contextual discovery of exhaustion amidst chronic viral infection, the lack of thorough inquiry into CD4 T-cell exhaustion is particularly surprising given their important role in orchestrating immune responses through T-helper and direct cytotoxic functions. Current work suggests that CD4 T-cell exhaustion may indeed be prevalent, and as CD4 T cells have been implicated in various disease pathologies, such exhaustion is likely to be clinically relevant. Defining phenotypic exhaustion in the various CD4 T-cell subsets and how it influences immune responses and disease severity will be crucial to understanding collective immune dysfunction in a variety of pathologies. In this review, we will discuss mechanistic and clinical evidence for CD4 T-cell exhaustion in cancer. Further insight into the derivation and manifestation of exhaustive processes in CD4 T cells could reveal novel therapeutic targets to abrogate CD4 T-cell exhaustion in cancer and induce a robust antitumor immune response.

T-cell dysfunction can strongly impact both physiologic and pathologic states. Among the known modes of T-cell dysfunction, exhaustion has garnered an increasing degree of recent attention. As exhaustion was initially described as a hyporesponsive T-cell state in chronic lymphocytic choriomeningitis viral (LCMV) infections (1–3), significant effort was initially aimed at characterizing exhaustion in virus-combating CD8 T cells, specifically. A hallmark of mice exposed to chronic infection with LCMV Clone-13, exhaustion has come to encompass a broad state of CD8 T-cell dysfunction resulting from persistent antigen exposure under suboptimal conditions (4), including inadequate CD4 T-cell help (5–7). It has evolved as a transcriptionally programmed and host-adaptive state designed to limit collateral immunologic damage in conditions of failed pathogen clearance and continued antigen exposure, establishing a “stalemate” of sorts between host and pathogen.

More recently, exhaustion has become an acknowledged mode of T-cell dysfunction in cancer as well (8, 9). Importantly, the upregulation of exhaustion-demarcating immune checkpoints by T cells has been associated with the development of tumor resistance to checkpoint blockade therapies (10). Although restoration of exhausted CD8 T-cell function is a primary goal for checkpoint inhibition, CD4 T cells are also liable to suffer exhaustion and contribute to rejuvenation of the antitumor immune response after checkpoint blockade. However, thorough investigations into the definition, prevalence, and mechanisms of CD4 exhaustion remain lacking. This presents a gap in our understanding of the summative immune dysfunction characterizing a number of disease states where CD4 T-cell function is relevant, including cancer.

CD4 T cells perform a wide variety of functions within the adaptive immune system and are best known for their role as T helper (Th) cells, including Th1, Th2, Th17, and regulatory T-cell (Treg) subsets. Importantly, CD4 T cells license dendritic cells (DC) to allow optimal priming of CD8 T cells, provide key signals for antibody class switching, promote bactericidal activity of phagocytes, recruit neutrophils, influence angiogenesis, and secrete cytokines, in addition to perhaps possessing direct cytotoxic functions (Fig. 1; refs. 11–13). Likewise, CD4 T cells appear to possess significant plasticity, allowing subsets to transition between one another, broadening their functional impact (14).

Figure 1.

Overview of CD4 T-cell functions. CD4 T cells are most well known for their Th cell functions (displayed on the right). Through recognition of the TCR of the peptide-MHC complex, CD4 T cells mediate increased maturation and activation of DCs. This process allows augmented CD8 T-cell effectors upon interaction with the activated DCs. Furthermore, CD4 T cells increase B-cell maturation, antibody class switching, and affinity maturation, and enhance phagocytosis within macrophages (Mφ). Aside from helper functions, CD4 T cells possess both direct and indirect tumor cytotoxicity capacities (displayed on the left). Direct cytotoxicity was demonstrated by cytotoxic CD4 T expressing class I–restricted T-cell–associated molecule (CRTAM). Indirect cytotoxicity could also be guided by CD4 T cells through interaction with antigen-presenting cells (APC) or natural killer cells. Adapted from an image created with BioRender.com.

Figure 1.

Overview of CD4 T-cell functions. CD4 T cells are most well known for their Th cell functions (displayed on the right). Through recognition of the TCR of the peptide-MHC complex, CD4 T cells mediate increased maturation and activation of DCs. This process allows augmented CD8 T-cell effectors upon interaction with the activated DCs. Furthermore, CD4 T cells increase B-cell maturation, antibody class switching, and affinity maturation, and enhance phagocytosis within macrophages (Mφ). Aside from helper functions, CD4 T cells possess both direct and indirect tumor cytotoxicity capacities (displayed on the left). Direct cytotoxicity was demonstrated by cytotoxic CD4 T expressing class I–restricted T-cell–associated molecule (CRTAM). Indirect cytotoxicity could also be guided by CD4 T cells through interaction with antigen-presenting cells (APC) or natural killer cells. Adapted from an image created with BioRender.com.

Close modal

CD4 T cells are strongly implicated in the development of antitumor responses (Table 1), as they can enhance tumoricidal activity of other antitumor effector cells, such as CD8 T cells and macrophages (6, 15, 16). Some CD4 subsets, particularly Th2 and Tregs, are known to negatively affect the antitumor response by decreasing antigen presentation and dampening T-cell effector functions, respectively. Furthermore, certain CD4 T cells appear able to directly lyse tumor cells (11, 12), and adoptive transfer of tumor-specific CD4 T cells alone has demonstrated impressive efficacy in some studies (17). Direct tumor cell recognition and killing by CD4 T cells requires class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC), and overexpression of class II MHC transactivator (CIITA) on murine mammary adenocarcinoma cells increased interferon-gamma (IFNγ) and granzyme B production in CD4 T cells and restricted tumor growth (18). These studies remain controversial, however, as many tumor cells will not have the antigen presentation machinery required to properly load peptides onto MHC-II. Nevertheless, CD4 T cells with a cytotoxic transcriptional profile have been found enriched in patients responding to immune checkpoint blockade (19).

Table 1.

Overview of CD4 populations and their contributions to tumor immunity.

T-cell subsetMaster regulatorCytokineFunctions within the tumor
Th1 Tbet IFNγ 
  • Activate macrophages to phagocytose

  • Promote recruitment of antigen-presenting cells

  • Enhance CD8 effector function

  • Inhibit angiogenesis

 
Th2 GATA3 IL4, IL5, IL13 
  • Recruit eosinophils

  • Inhibit antigen processing by dendritic cells

 
Th17 RORγt IL17 
  • Promote angiogenesis

  • Recruit neutrophils

 
Regulatory T-cell FoxP3 IL10, TGFβ • Decrease effector functions of tumor-infiltrating T cells 
Cytotoxic CD4 T cells Runx3 Perforin, granzymes • Direct tumor cytotoxicity 
T-cell subsetMaster regulatorCytokineFunctions within the tumor
Th1 Tbet IFNγ 
  • Activate macrophages to phagocytose

  • Promote recruitment of antigen-presenting cells

  • Enhance CD8 effector function

  • Inhibit angiogenesis

 
Th2 GATA3 IL4, IL5, IL13 
  • Recruit eosinophils

  • Inhibit antigen processing by dendritic cells

 
Th17 RORγt IL17 
  • Promote angiogenesis

  • Recruit neutrophils

 
Regulatory T-cell FoxP3 IL10, TGFβ • Decrease effector functions of tumor-infiltrating T cells 
Cytotoxic CD4 T cells Runx3 Perforin, granzymes • Direct tumor cytotoxicity 

Abbreviations: FoxP3, Forkhead Box P3; GATA3, GATA binding protein 3; IFNγ, interferon gamma; IL, interleukin; RORγt, retinoic acid receptor–related orphan nuclear receptor gamma; Runx3, RUNX Family Transcription Factor 3; Tbet, T-box expressed in T cells; TGFβ, transforming growth factor beta.

Given the diverse repertoire of CD4 T-cell capacities, dysfunction in this compartment is assuredly relevant. In this review, we will discuss the current best evidence for the delineation and significance of CD4 T-cell exhaustion in cancer. A brief overview of CD4 T-cell exhaustion in chronic infections, transplantation, and autoimmune diseases will also provide context across pertinent pathologies. Understanding these processes is anticipated to aid in identifying novel therapeutic targets and considerations for improving the antitumor responses.

The framework for our current understanding of CD4 T-cell exhaustion is generated from the more extensively studied CD8 T-cell exhaustion, elegantly reviewed by McLane and colleagues (20). When antigen clearance fails and exposure is maintained, as in the setting of chronic infection or cancer, an exhausted T-cell phenotype may emerge. A primary feature of exhausted T cells is the sustained coexpression of multiple inhibitory surface receptors, referred to commonly as immune checkpoints. The function of these checkpoints is to permit protective curbing of T-cell activity following immune activation. The “classical” immune checkpoints include cytotoxic T lymphocyte–associated protein 4 (CTLA4) and programmed cell death protein 1 (PD-1). Newer “alternative” checkpoints include molecules such as T-cell immunoglobulin and mucin-domain containing-3 (TIM3); lymphocyte-activation gene 3 (LAG3); B- and T-lymphocyte attenuator (BTLA); 2B4; T-cell immunoreceptor with Ig and ITIM domains (TIGIT); and SLAM Family Member 6 (SLAMF6; refs. 21, 22). These inhibitory receptors (checkpoints) are known to be expressed on exhausted T cells, with mounting checkpoint expression associated with more severe phenotypes (8, 10). The typical characteristics of CD8 T-cell exhaustion include antigen load–dependent and temporally progressive loss of effector activity (8, 23, 24), loss of proliferative capacity (25, 26), altered expression of transcription factors (27, 28), loss of antigen-independent homeostatic proliferation (29), and modified epigenetic landscapes (30–32) and metabolic requirements (28, 33, 34). In turn, disruption of the PD-1/programmed death ligand 1 (PD-L1) pathway, in particular, has demonstrated the capacity to reverse features of the exhausted phenotype and restore T-cell proliferative and effector function (35).

Recent evidence suggests that the exhausted phenotype in CD8 T cells is not homogeneous and includes lineage spanning, stage-like “progenitor” (SLAMF6+TIM3) and “terminally-differentiated” (SLAMF6TIM3+) subtypes (21, 26), with varied capacities for effector function and proliferation dispersed among the subgroups. Terminally exhausted CD8 T cells are further characterized by higher levels of PD-1 on their surface. Whereas progenitor exhausted CD8 T cells remain capable of co-producing multiple cytokines and can proliferate in vivo, terminally exhausted CD8 T cells are limited to single cytokine production and upregulation of granzyme B. Furthermore, only progenitor exhausted subsets are capable of responding to anti–PD-1 treatment (21, 26). SLAMF6-positive CD8 T cells express the transcription factor T-cell factor 1 (TCF1) (21), which has been linked to the preservation of effector functions (36). Loss of TCF1 with concomitant upregulation of multiple coinhibitory receptors is associated with the terminally differentiated exhaustion phenotype and a further decline in effector functions (21) and/or adoption of immunoregulatory function (37). While exhausted CD8 T cells retain the ability to recognize antigen through their T-cell receptor (TCR), antigen exposure fails to elicit a robust, meaningful cytotoxic response (23).

Our current grasp of CD4 T-cell exhaustion is decidedly anemic when compared with the above understanding we have acquired for CD8s. To begin, an accepted definition of CD4 T-cell exhaustion has not yet been established, limiting the capacity to properly assign the term definitively. Much of the research on CD4 T-cell exhaustion to date has focused merely on the expression versus absence of coinhibitory receptors and/or cytokine production, with data being suggestive of an exhausted state (Fig. 2). Further research is required to determine whether additional criteria delineating CD8 T-cell exhaustion, including loss of antigen-independent homeostatic proliferation (29, 38, 39), alterations in metabolic profiles (28, 33, 34), and unique epigenetic features (30–32), also apply to exhausted CD4 T cells. Likewise, it will be crucial to understand whether CD4 exhaustion evolves in a similar stage- and lineage-dependent manner to CD8 T cells (30, 31), and whether or not there are differing relative susceptibilities to and impacts for exhaustion in the various CD4 subsets.

Figure 2.

Consequences of CD4 T-cell exhaustion on CD4 Th functions. Although the details of CD4 T-cell exhaustion remain to be deciphered, negative effects on proliferation, cytokine production, B-cell help, and CD8 effector functions have been reported. In addition, CD4 T cells with reduced effector functions upregulate immune-regulatory proteins, such as T-cell immunoglobulin and mucin domain-3 (TIM3) and PD-1, paralleling phenotypes observed in exhausted CD8 T cells. Whether CD4 T-cell exhaustion negatively impacts macrophage activation and direct tumor cytotoxicity remains to be determined. Further research is required to determine whether loss of antigen independent homeostatic proliferation and alterations in epigenetic and metabolic profiles are features of exhausted CD4 T cells, similar to exhausted CD8 T cells. Abbreviations: Bat3: human leukocyte antigen B (HLA-B)–associated transcript 3; CREM: CAMP responsive element modulator; Fut7: fucosyltransferase 7; IRF4: interferon regulatory factor 4; Klf4: Krüppel-like factor 4; NFAT: nuclear factor of activated T cells; NFIL3: nuclear factor, interleukin 3 regulated; NR4A1: nuclear receptor subfamily 4 group A member 1; PRDM1: PR/SET domain 1 (encodes Blimp1); PTPN22: protein tyrosine phosphatase, non-receptor type 22; Zbtb7b: zinc finger and BTB domain containing 7B (encodes ThPOK). Adapted from an image created with BioRender.com.

Figure 2.

Consequences of CD4 T-cell exhaustion on CD4 Th functions. Although the details of CD4 T-cell exhaustion remain to be deciphered, negative effects on proliferation, cytokine production, B-cell help, and CD8 effector functions have been reported. In addition, CD4 T cells with reduced effector functions upregulate immune-regulatory proteins, such as T-cell immunoglobulin and mucin domain-3 (TIM3) and PD-1, paralleling phenotypes observed in exhausted CD8 T cells. Whether CD4 T-cell exhaustion negatively impacts macrophage activation and direct tumor cytotoxicity remains to be determined. Further research is required to determine whether loss of antigen independent homeostatic proliferation and alterations in epigenetic and metabolic profiles are features of exhausted CD4 T cells, similar to exhausted CD8 T cells. Abbreviations: Bat3: human leukocyte antigen B (HLA-B)–associated transcript 3; CREM: CAMP responsive element modulator; Fut7: fucosyltransferase 7; IRF4: interferon regulatory factor 4; Klf4: Krüppel-like factor 4; NFAT: nuclear factor of activated T cells; NFIL3: nuclear factor, interleukin 3 regulated; NR4A1: nuclear receptor subfamily 4 group A member 1; PRDM1: PR/SET domain 1 (encodes Blimp1); PTPN22: protein tyrosine phosphatase, non-receptor type 22; Zbtb7b: zinc finger and BTB domain containing 7B (encodes ThPOK). Adapted from an image created with BioRender.com.

Close modal

Original evidence: chronic infections

As CD8 T-cell exhaustion was first defined in chronic LCMV infection, this remains a logical place to begin when analyzing the evidence for a similar exhausted state among CD4 T cells. Compared with acute infections, chronic LCMV infections induce markedly greater expression of exhaustion-suggestive immune checkpoints on CD4 T cells (40, 41). Upregulation of these same inhibitory receptors typical of CD8 exhaustion has also been identified on CD4 T cells in other chronic and recurrent infections, suggesting an analogous CD4 T-cell exhaustion phenotype (42–44). Similar to what is seen with CD8 T cells, antigen-specific CD4 T cells (45–49) and CD4 T cells from infected tissues (50, 51) express higher levels of the relevant coinhibitory receptors, drawing a parallel role for antigen exposure in the induction of the seemingly matched CD4 exhausted state. Accordingly, increased coinhibitory receptor expression is generally associated with more advanced disease (52–56), while successful disease treatment correlates in turn with reduced expression of the same markers (56–58). However, upregulation of inhibitory markers is not sufficient to call a cell exhausted, as some coinhibitory receptors are also activation markers (59).

Importantly, then, functional deficits are also observed amidst the phenotypically exhausted CD4 T-cell compartment following chronic infection (45, 60–63). In LCMV in particular, CD4 T-cell differentiation in the presence of persistent antigen resulted in upregulation of coinhibitory molecules (62), premature contraction of the antigen-specific immune population (41, 61), reduced cytokine production (41, 61), decreased splenic motility (62), and poor recall responses upon a secondary challenge (61). Reduced CD4 effector functions and increased expression of inhibitory molecules could be induced upon exposure of CD4 T cells to TNF (64) and fibrinogen-like 2 (FGL2; ref. 65). A link between decreased performance of CD4 T cells and exhaustion was established through increased motility and cytokine production following anti–PD-1 treatment (41, 62), although recovery of function was inconsistent (46, 59, 63, 66–68).

Exhaustion is also characterized (and confirmed) by prescribed and stereotyped transcriptional programs. Various studies examining transcriptional programs within CD4 T cells have provided mechanistic insight into factors that may be involved in the establishment of CD4 T-cell exhaustion during LCMV or other chronic infection response. Such studies suggest roles for upregulation of IKZF2 (encoding Helios; ref. 42), Klf4 (42), protein tyrosine phosphatase, nonreceptor type 22 (PTPN22; ref. 69), cAMP-responsive element modulator (CREM; ref. 69), and PR/SET domain 1 (PRDM1, encodes Blimp1; ref. 45). Likewise, exhaustion in CD4 T cells has been observed with loss or downregulation of ThPOK (70) and nuclear factor of activated T cells (NFAT; ref. 71).

Not all effector functions of CD4 T cells are necessarily compromised during chronic infections: perforin (72) and granzyme B (73) production in CD4 T cells is increased in patients with HIV when compared with healthy controls, for instance. Interestingly, such regain of cytotoxic function has also been described for “terminally” exhausted CD8 T cells (21). Therefore, the acquisition or retention of these functions might simply indicate varying exhaustion stages, again eliciting similarities with observations made amidst CD8 T-cell exhaustion.

Evidence and significance in cancer

Cytotoxic CD8 T cells promote antitumor immunity that can be correspondingly restricted by their tumor-induced diversion down a pathway toward exhaustion (8, 9, 74–76). Yet, a successful antitumor immune response requires the coordination of a variety of non–T cells constituting the tumor microenvironment (TME), including macrophages, DCs, B cells, and others. Given the role CD4 T cells play in orchestrating the responses by each of these cell types, the potential impact that exhaustion might have amidst the tumor-infiltrating or even systemic CD4 population is substantial. Likewise, the direct cytotoxic role that CD4 T cells can have in mediating antitumor immunity (11–13) makes them a particularly germane population in cancer. As an extension, restoration of exhausted CD4 T-cell function by checkpoint blockade, if feasible, may contribute significant clinical benefit in tumors, either by improving direct CD4 antitumor activity or increasing CD4 helper functions.

Canonical and alternative inhibitory receptors suggestive of exhaustion on CD4 T cells (PD1, CTLA4, LAG3, TIM3, TIGIT) have been identified in multiple solid tumors and hematologic malignancies (77–82) in both humans and mice (Table 2). In many cases, similar to that seen with chronic infection, the expression of such checkpoints has been associated with more advanced disease states and diminished progression-free survival (83–85). Furthermore, successful anticancer therapies have been associated with reductions in the level of these markers on the surface of CD4 T cells (86–88), while failure to achieve complete remission and/or disease relapse has positively correlated with their persistent or enhanced expression (86, 89, 90–92).

Table 2.

Overview of coinhibitory and costimulatory markers assessed in various primary tumors. Markers were either assessed as single positive or double positive.

Primary tumorCoinhibitory markersCostimulatory markerMain conclusions
Melanoma PD1, CTLA4, LAG3, TIGIT, TIM3 2B4 • Continuous antigen stimulation decreases antitumor activity (101, 102) 
   • Long-term remission in murine models after αLAG3 + αPDL1 (112, 113) 
Lung cancer PD1, CTLA4, LAG3, BTLA, CD69, TIM3 2B4 • Patients with a high CD4 PD-1+ frequency had decreased overall and progression-free survival, independent of clinical characteristics (145) 
GBM PD1, TIM3, LAG3, CTLA4  
  • Majority of PD-1+ CD4 T cells were IL7Rα negative (104)

  • Increased proliferation upon αPD1 observed only in the presence of PD1- CD4 T cells (95)

  • PD1hi Tregs exhibit decreased suppressive functions and increased IFNγ production (114)

  • Clonal expansion was observed among tumor-infiltrating CD4 T cells (8)

 
Breast PD1, TIM3  
  • αPD-1 treatment increased TCR signaling (97), proliferation (146), cytokine production (98)

  • Overexpression of MHC-II on tumor cells reduces exhaustion in CD4 T cells and increases tumor control (18)

 
Head and neck TIGIT, LAG3, TIM3, PD1, CD69  • αTIGIT delayed tumor progression, although direct effect on CD4 T cells not assessed (103) 
Gastrointestinal PD1, CTLA4, TIM3, LAG3 ICOS 
  • Checkpoint inhibitors decreased suppressive ability of Tregs (147) and partially restored effector functions (84, 94)

  • TIM3+ cells expressed increased cycle-dependent kinase inhibitors, preventing cell-cycle entry. αTIM3 restored cell proliferation (100)

 
AML PD1, CD57, CD69, CTLA4, TIM3, LAG3 ICOS • αCD86 and ICOS-ligand prevented the emergence of exhausted CD4 T cells (148) 
CLL PD1, TIM3, TIGIT 2B4, CD226 • αTIGIT impaired IFNγ and IL10 production in the presence of tumor cells the TIGIT ligand (CD155; ref. 111) 
Multiple myeloma PD1, TIM3, CTLA4 CD40L • Gradual decrease in CD40L expression with more advanced disease (149) 
Primary tumorCoinhibitory markersCostimulatory markerMain conclusions
Melanoma PD1, CTLA4, LAG3, TIGIT, TIM3 2B4 • Continuous antigen stimulation decreases antitumor activity (101, 102) 
   • Long-term remission in murine models after αLAG3 + αPDL1 (112, 113) 
Lung cancer PD1, CTLA4, LAG3, BTLA, CD69, TIM3 2B4 • Patients with a high CD4 PD-1+ frequency had decreased overall and progression-free survival, independent of clinical characteristics (145) 
GBM PD1, TIM3, LAG3, CTLA4  
  • Majority of PD-1+ CD4 T cells were IL7Rα negative (104)

  • Increased proliferation upon αPD1 observed only in the presence of PD1- CD4 T cells (95)

  • PD1hi Tregs exhibit decreased suppressive functions and increased IFNγ production (114)

  • Clonal expansion was observed among tumor-infiltrating CD4 T cells (8)

 
Breast PD1, TIM3  
  • αPD-1 treatment increased TCR signaling (97), proliferation (146), cytokine production (98)

  • Overexpression of MHC-II on tumor cells reduces exhaustion in CD4 T cells and increases tumor control (18)

 
Head and neck TIGIT, LAG3, TIM3, PD1, CD69  • αTIGIT delayed tumor progression, although direct effect on CD4 T cells not assessed (103) 
Gastrointestinal PD1, CTLA4, TIM3, LAG3 ICOS 
  • Checkpoint inhibitors decreased suppressive ability of Tregs (147) and partially restored effector functions (84, 94)

  • TIM3+ cells expressed increased cycle-dependent kinase inhibitors, preventing cell-cycle entry. αTIM3 restored cell proliferation (100)

 
AML PD1, CD57, CD69, CTLA4, TIM3, LAG3 ICOS • αCD86 and ICOS-ligand prevented the emergence of exhausted CD4 T cells (148) 
CLL PD1, TIM3, TIGIT 2B4, CD226 • αTIGIT impaired IFNγ and IL10 production in the presence of tumor cells the TIGIT ligand (CD155; ref. 111) 
Multiple myeloma PD1, TIM3, CTLA4 CD40L • Gradual decrease in CD40L expression with more advanced disease (149) 

As with CD8 exhaustion, a number of coinhibitory receptors may also serve to denote T-cell activation (59). Therefore, their expression alone is not sufficient to signal the true emergence of exhaustion. Functional and transcriptomic correlates are needed. Ultimately, it is a balance between costimulatory and coinhibitory signals that provide a gain adjustment on the immune response. Currently, however, such phenotypic and functional assessments of tumor-infiltrating CD4 T cells remain somewhat lacking. Functional deficits in CD4 proliferation, cytokine production, signaling, and provision of B-cell help have varied according to tumor type and source of CD4 T cells (93–99). Nonetheless, current studies in a variety of cancers indicate a correlative relationship between typical markers of T-cell exhaustion on CD4 T cells and the degree of disease severity. Likewise, at least partial restoration of CD4 effector functions has been observed after treatment with checkpoint inhibitors (Table 2; refs. 84, 93, 97, 100).

To evaluate whether apparent CD4 T-cell exhaustion parallels the development of CD8 T-cell exhaustion, Rausch and colleagues (101) and Malandro and colleagues (102) investigated the role of antigen stimulation on CD4 T-cell function using murine melanoma models. Persistently increased antigen availability reduced CD4 proliferation, cytokine production, and antitumor responses and increased checkpoint expression on CD4 T cells. Checkpoint inhibition induced only a variable recovery of CD4 effector functions in their hands. Furthermore, clinical observations demonstrate that tumor-infiltrating CD4 T cells express higher levels of coinhibitory markers compared with circulatory (98, 103, 104) or adjacent tissue-infiltrating CD4 T cells (100, 105, 106). These data indicate that perpetual antigen encounters can induce a severe, and potentially irreversible, exhaustion phenotype that mimics terminal exhaustion in CD8 T cells (21).

To further investigate parallels between the development of CD4 T-cell and CD8 T-cell exhaustion and differentiation states, Fu and colleagues examined the transition from progenitor exhaustion (SLAMF6+TIM3) to terminal exhaustion (SLAMF6TIM3+; ref. 21) occurring among CD4 T cells within a murine melanoma model. They observed a downregulation of TCF1 and SLAMF6 on tumor-infiltrating CD4 T cells compared with CD4 T cells in the spleen, indicating more prevalent differentiation into the terminally exhausted state within tumors. Furthermore, treatment with anti–PD-L1 resulted in an increase in TCF1 and a decrease in TIM3 and LAG3 on CD4 T cells, indicating maintenance of the progenitor exhausted subset (107). These data were corroborated by experiments performed in human samples of head and neck, ovarian, and cervical tumors (108). In contrast to terminally exhausted CD8 T cells, terminal exhaustion in CD4 T cells was represented by the expression of CD39, rather than TIM3. CD39+ cells were found to have higher levels of PD-1, produce fewer cytokines, and were more likely to produce a single cytokine (predominantly IFNγ) rather than coproduce multiple cytokines. Treatment with anti–PD-1 increased cytokine production, upregulated CD40 ligand (CD40L), and increased DC maturation and CD8 proliferation, indicating increased CD4 helper functions (108). Paralleling CD8 T-cell exhaustion, CD39+ CD4 T cells expressed the highest level of thymocyte selection-associated high mobility group box (TOX; ref. 109) and lost expression of TCF1 (21). The parallel of increased TOX expression with that described in CD8 exhaustion is of particular interest, as TOX has recently been found to initiate the epigenetic changes associated with the exhausted phenotype (110). Epigenetic changes are hallmarks of CD8 T-cell exhaustion (30–32), and this similarity should drive further investigation into the epigenetic landscape of CD4 T-cell exhaustion.

Drawing additional similarities to terminally exhausted CD8 T cells, studies suggest that exhausted CD4 T cells may actually gain certain additional functionality, as the acquisition of noncanonical T-cell function was observed among putatively exhausted CD4 T cells in solid tumors. For instance, C-X-C Motif Chemokine ligand 13 (CXCL13) was found to be exclusively produced by PD1hi CD4 T cells in non–small cell lung cancer (106), suggesting a skew toward effector function in what otherwise resembled exhausted CD4 T cells. Conversely, increased effector function might not translate to increased tumoricidal activity. For instance, enhanced IFNγ production was observed in CD4 T cells positive for the inhibitory marker TIGIT in patients with chronic lymphocytic leukemia. In spite of the improved secretion of proinflammatory cytokines, TIGIT expression on CD4 T cells was also associated with more advanced disease, and TIGIT blockade hindered tumor cell viability in vitro, despite also decreasing IFNγ production (111).

Mouse tumor models have been utilized to better evaluate the impact and relevance of CD4 T cells and CD4 T-cell exhaustion for antitumor immunity. Adoptive transfer of melanoma-specific CD4 T cells into a RAG1 knockout recipient resulted in tumor regression. However, a subset of mice presented with tumor relapse. CD4 T cells taken from the recurrent tumors expressed fewer cytokines, increased levels of coinhibitory receptors (112), and were unable to induce tumor regression when transplanted into a secondary tumor-bearing host, suggesting the emergence of response-limiting exhaustion (113). Meanwhile, combination therapy with anti–PD-L1 and anti-LAG3 decreased checkpoint expression, increased CD4 effector functions, and resulted in durable tumor control (112, 113). The lack of CD8 T cells in this model indicates a significant role for CD4 T-cell exhaustion in facilitating tumor escape. Furthermore, these data suggest that checkpoint blockade strategies aimed at CD4 T cells could very well improve tumor control.

Tumor models have likewise been utilized to shed light on important considerations for CD4 T-cell exhaustion, including the relative frequency of exhaustion within the various CD4 subsets. For instance, examining the directly cytotoxic CD4 T-cell subset, we return to an aforementioned study in which tumor cells overexpressing CIITA were generated to permit CD4 recognition of class II MHC-expressing tumors (18). Despite increased cytotoxic CD4 T-cell–mediated tumor control of these tumors, outgrowth eventually occurred, with associated upregulation of coinhibitory markers on tumor-infiltrating CD4 T cells. This expansion was reversed with anti-CTLA4 treatment, highlighting the role of CD4 T-cell exhaustion in tumor progression, as well as the capacity for cytotoxic CD4 T cells, specifically, to undergo an exhaustion program (18).

Interestingly, exhaustion-indicative expression of immune checkpoints has also been observed on the Treg subset of CD4 T cells in the tumors of patients with glioblastoma multiforme (GBM; ref. 114) and hepatocellular carcinoma (115). This suggests that exhaustion among CD4 T cells may not be limited solely to effector CD4 T cells. PD1-expressing Tregs in patients with GBM demonstrate enrichment of exhaustion-related genes and decreased suppressive capacities (114), indicating that suppressive functions may be exhaustion-susceptible as well. Given the substantial role Tregs play limiting cellular immunity in GBM (and other cancers; refs. 116, 117), selective strategies for reversing exhaustion in cytotoxic and Th1-type CD4 T cells while maintaining or enhancing it in Tregs may represent challenging but worthwhile future directions. Accordingly, understanding whether exhaustion-inducing mechanisms are the same in each of these CD4 subsets becomes an important endeavor.

In addition to exhaustion, anergy (118, 119) and senescence (120) have been recognized as modes of T-cell dysfunction that negatively influence antitumor immunity (121, 122). Although these states overlap with regard to various functional and/or phenotypic elements, the mechanisms eliciting the phenotypes are distinct. In contrast to the relatively insidious development of T-cell exhaustion following continuous antigen stimulation, for instance, T-cell senescence is associated with cell-cycle arrest due to shortening of telomeric ends or danger signals, such as oxidative stress (123, 124). Likewise, anergy develops at priming, subsequent to excessive stimulation of the TCR without proper costimulatory signals. Although inhibitory receptors such as PD1, CTLA4, TIM3, and LAG3 are more commonly associated with T-cell exhaustion, other markers, such as CD57 and killer cell lectin-like receptor subfamily G member 1 (KLRG1), are more commonly associated with senescence (124). Unlike senescence T cells, however, progenitor exhausted T cells are capable of responding to checkpoint blockade (21), allowing restoration of function. Further explorations will be required to further delineate these hypo- or unresponsive states and unravel the relative contributions that each of these modes of CD4 dysfunction makes to hindering antitumor immunity.

Ultimately, the data reviewed above begin to establish CD4 T-cell exhaustion as a unique differentiation state impacting antitumor immunity, paralleling exhaustion in CD8 T cells. Further comparisons, including epigenetic and metabolic profiles between exhausted and nonexhausted CD4 T-cell states, will be essential. These experiments will increase our understanding of the complex immune responses generated to cancer and persistent infections and could provide novel therapeutic targets. Additional insights should be gathered by evaluating other pathologies where CD4 exhaustion has been identified. In addition to cancer and chronic infections, these can include transplantation and autoimmune diseases.

Salient studies in transplantation and autoimmune diseases

Studies into transplantation and autoimmune diseases can help shed light on the possibility of modulating CD4 T-cell exhaustion as a therapeutic strategy. In contrast to cancer and chronic infections, CD4 T cells in transplantation and autoimmunity are a source of undesirable activity and collateral host tissue damage. In the case of hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) and solid organ transplantation, CD4 T cells have been demonstrated to play a significant role in allograft rejection (125, 126) by providing help to the two major cell subsets responsible for tissue damage: cytotoxic donor-specific CD8 T cells and B cells (127). Therefore, inducing specific CD4 T-cell tolerance (128–130) or exhaustion could potentially mitigate the need for systemic immunosuppression by selectively restraining graft-specific effector cells while leaving the remainder of the immune system capable of responding to foreign antigens, reducing the risk of infections and malignancy.

Upregulation of coinhibitory molecules on CD4 T cells is observed following HSC (131, 132) and solid organ transplantation (133). Transgenic overexpression of TIM3 on CD4 T cells resulted in decreased proinflammatory cytokine production and prevented immune-mediated graft pathology (134), indicating a direct role for TIM3 on CD4 T cells in the prevention of rejection. Mechanistically, loss of IFN regulatory factor 4 (IRF4) or Fucosyltransferase 7 (Fut7) in CD4 T cells induced graft tolerance through the establishment of exhaustion in these cells. Graft rejection could be initiated in the early phases after transplant upon treatment with monoclonal antibodies interfering with the PD-1–PD-L1 pathway (135, 136). However, irreversible dysfunction was established in IRF4 knockout (KO) CD4 T cells if anti–PD-1 treatment was delayed until 30 days posttransplant (135).

Much like transplantation, the management of autoimmune diseases frequently involves systemic immunosuppression, and the role of CD4 T cells in autoimmune pathology has long been recognized (137, 138). Conversely, a negative correlation between CD4 inhibitory receptor expression and disease severity has been observed in a rheumatoid arthritis population (139), although this has not been a consistent finding (140). Insights into the role of CD4 T-cell exhaustion and its influence on disease severity in autoimmunity comes from mechanistic studies evaluating Nuclear Receptor Subfamily 4 Group A Member 1 (NR4A1), Nuclear Factor Interleukin 3 Regulation (NFIL3), and human leukocyte antigen B (HLA-B)–associated transcript 3 (Bat3). Upregulation of NR4A1 and NFIL3 and downregulation of Bat3 increased expression of exhaustion markers on CD4 T cells and decreased cytokine production and disease severity (141–143). In addition, persistent stimulation of CD4 T cells with endogenous peptides resulted in loss of cytokine production and proliferation, upregulation of inhibitory markers, and delayed onset of autoimmune diabetes (144).

Compared with CD8 T-cell exhaustion, the impact of CD4 T-cell exhaustion in cancer and other disease states has remained relatively underappreciated. Current studies have provided mostly phenotypic data, and investigations into additional criteria established for CD8 T-cell exhaustion, such as metabolic profiles and epigenetic landscapes, will be required to determine whether CD4 exhaustion likewise comprises a distinct and progressing T-cell differentiation state. Our current mechanistic understanding of factors involved in CD4 T-cell exhaustion is summarized in Fig. 2. Further evaluation of CD4 T-cell–specific factors will be essential to increase our understanding of the mechanistic derivations of exhaustion in this population. Analysis of factors associated with CD4 T-cell exhaustion in other pathologies should be extended into tumor models to evaluate similarities and differences in mechanistic determinants. It remains to be seen whether the processes underlying CD4 T-cell exhaustion are similar across different disease pathologies and CD4 subsets, or whether different convergent transcriptional programs happen to result in the same terminally differentiated fate. Furthermore, in-depth assessment of the potentially differential susceptibility of various CD4 T-cell subsets to exhaustion will be required to increase our understanding of its consequences, as well as the relative contribution of each CD4 T-cell subset to antitumor immunity. Finally, examination of the dynamics of the initiation and progression of CD4 T-cell exhaustion and assessment of the role of tumor cells and the TME in the process will be invaluable to understanding parallels and differences between CD4 and CD8 T-cell exhaustion. Crystallizing these insights will be vital to increase our understanding of CD4 T-cell exhaustion and its therapeutic implications.

No disclosures were reported.

Figures were generated with BioRender.com.

This work was supported by the National Institutes of Health (T32 AI052077 to S.J. Lorrey) and by CRI Lloyd J Old STAR (CRI3922 to P.E. Fecci).

The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked advertisement in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.

1.
Gallimore
A
,
Glithero
A
,
Godkin
A
,
Tissot
AC
,
Pluckthun
A
,
Elliott
T
, et al
Induction and exhaustion of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes visualized using soluble tetrameric major histocompatibility complex class I-peptide complexes
.
J Exp Med
1998
;
187
:
1383
93
.
2.
Moskophidis
D
,
Lechner
F
,
Pircher
H
,
Zinkernagel
RM
. 
Virus persistence in acutely infected immunocompetent mice by exhaustion of antiviral cytotoxic effector T cells
.
Nature
1993
;
362
:
758
61
.
3.
Zajac
AJ
,
Blattman
JN
,
Murali-Krishna
K
,
Sourdive
DJ
,
Suresh
M
,
Altman
JD
, et al
Viral immune evasion due to persistence of activated T cells without effector function
.
J Exp Med
1998
;
188
:
2205
13
.
4.
Wherry
E
,
Blattman
J
,
Murali-Krishna
K
,
van der Most
R
,
Ahmed
R
. 
Viral persistence alters CD8 T-cell Immunodominance and tissue distribution and results in distinct stages of functional impairment
.
J Virol
2003
;
77
:
4911
27
.
5.
Phares
TW
,
Stohlman
SA
,
Hwang
M
,
Min
B
,
Hinton
DR
,
Bergmann
CC
. 
CD4 T cells promote CD8 T cell immunity at the priming and effector site during viral encephalitis
.
J Virol
2012
;
86
:
2416
.
6.
Ahrends
T
,
Spanjaard
A
,
Pilzecker
B
,
Bąbała
N
,
Bovens
A
,
Xiao
Y
, et al
CD4+ T cell help confers a cytotoxic T cell effector program including coinhibitory receptor downregulation and increased tissue invasiveness
.
Immunity
2017
;
47
:
848
61
.
7.
Matloubian
M
,
Concepcion
RJ
,
Ahmed
R
. 
CD4+ T cells are required to sustain CD8+ cytotoxic T-cell responses during chronic viral infection
.
J Virol
1994
;
68
:
8056
63
.
8.
Woroniecka
K
,
Chongsathidkiet
P
,
Rhodin
KE
,
Kemeny
HR
,
Dechant
CA
,
Farber
SH
, et al
T cell exhaustion signatures vary with tumor type and are severe in glioblastoma
.
Clin Cancer Res
2018
;
24
:
4175
86
.
9.
Baitsch
L
,
Baumgaertner
P
,
Devêvre
E
,
Raghav
SK
,
Legat
A
,
Barba
L
, et al
Exhaustion of tumor-specific CD8+ T cells in metastases from melanoma patients
.
J Clin Invest
2011
;
121
:
2350
60
.
10.
Koyama
S
,
Akbay
EA
,
Li
YY
,
Herter-Sprie
GS
,
Buczkowski
KA
,
Richards
WG
, et al
Adaptive resistance to therapeutic PD-1 blockade is associated with upregulation of alternative immune checkpoints
.
Nat Commun
2016
;
7
:
10501
.
11.
Xie
Y
,
Akpinarli
A
,
Maris
C
,
Hipkiss
EL
,
Lane
M
,
Kwon
EKM
, et al
Naive tumor-specific CD4+ T cells differentiated in vivo eradicate established melanoma
.
J Exp Med
2010
;
207
:
651
67
.
12.
Quezada
SA
,
Simpson
TR
,
Peggs
KS
,
Merghoub
T
,
Vider
J
,
Fan
X
, et al
Tumor-reactive CD4+ T cells develop cytotoxic activity and eradicate large established melanoma after transfer into lymphopenic hosts
.
J Exp Med
2010
;
207
:
637
50
.
13.
Takeuchi
A
,
Badr
MESG
,
Miyauchi
K
,
Ishihara
C
,
Onishi
R
,
Guo
Z
, et al
CRT AM determines the CD4+ cytotoxic T lymphocyte lineage
.
J Exp Med
2016
;
213
:
123
38
.
14.
Caza
T
,
Landas
S
. 
Functional and phenotypic plasticity of CD4+ T cell subsets
.
Biomed Res Int
2015
;
2015
:
521957
.
15.
Busselaar
J
,
Tian
S
,
van Eenennaam
H
,
Borst
J
. 
Helpless priming sends CD8+ T cells on the road to exhaustion
.
Front Immunol
2020
;
11
:
2637
.
16.
Tay
RE
,
Richardson
EK
,
Toh
HC
. 
Revisiting the role of CD4+ T cells in cancer immunotherapy—new insights into old paradigms
.
Cancer Gene Ther
2021
;
28
:
5
17
.
17.
Perez-Diez
A
,
Joncker
NT
,
Choi
K
,
Chan
WFN
,
Anderson
CC
,
Lantz
O
, et al
CD4 cells can be more efficient at tumor rejection than CD8 cells
.
Blood
2007
;
109
:
5346
54
.
18.
McCaw
TR
,
Li
M
,
Starenki
D
,
Cooper
SJ
,
Liu
M
,
Meza-Perez
S
, et al
The expression of MHC class II molecules on murine breast tumors delays T-cell exhaustion, expands the T-cell repertoire, and slows tumor growth
.
Cancer Immunol Immunother
2019
;
68
:
175
88
.
19.
Oh
DY
,
Kwek
SS
,
Raju
SS
,
Li
T
,
McCarthy
E
,
Chow
E
, et al
Intratumoral CD4+ T cells mediate anti-tumor cytotoxicity in human bladder cancer
.
Cell
2020
;
181
:
1612
25
.
20.
McLane
LM
,
Abdel-Hakeem
MS
,
Wherry
EJ
. 
CD8 T cell exhaustion during chronic viral infection and cancer
.
Annu Rev Immunol
2019
;
37
:
457
95
.
21.
Miller
BC
,
Sen
DR
,
Al Abosy
R
,
Bi
K
,
Virkud
YV
,
LaFleur
MW
, et al
Subsets of exhausted CD8+ T cells differentially mediate tumor control and respond to checkpoint blockade
.
Nat Immunol
2019
;
20
:
326
36
.
22.
Beltra
JC
,
Manne
S
,
Abdel-Hakeem
MS
,
Kurachi
M
,
Giles
JR
,
Chen
Z
, et al
Developmental relationships of four exhausted CD8+ T cell subsets reveals underlying transcriptional and epigenetic landscape control mechanisms
.
Immunity
2020
;
52
:
825
41
.
23.
Fuller
MJ
,
Zajac
AJ
. 
Ablation of CD8 and CD4 T cell responses by high viral loads
.
J Immunol
2003
;
170
:
477
86
.
24.
Fuller
MJ
,
Khanolkar
A
,
Tebo
AE
,
Zajac
AJ
. 
Maintenance, loss, and resurgence of T cell responses during acute, protracted, and chronic viral infections
.
J Immunol
2004
;
172
:
4204
14
.
25.
Paley
MA
,
Kroy
DC
,
Odorizzi
PM
,
Johnnidis
JB
,
Dolfi
DV
,
Barnett
BE
, et al
Progenitor and terminal subsets of CD8+ T cells cooperate to contain chronic viral infection
.
Science
2012
;
338
:
1220
5
.
26.
Blackburn
SD
,
Shin
H
,
Freeman
GJ
,
Wherry
EJ
. 
Selective expansion of a subset of exhausted CD8 T cells by αPD-L1 blockade
.
PNAS
2008
;
105
:
15016
21
.
27.
Wherry
EJ
,
Kurachi
M
. 
Molecular and cellular insights into T cell exhaustion
.
Nat Rev Immunol
2015
;
15
:
486
.
28.
Wherry
EJ
,
Ha
S-J
,
Kaech
SM
,
Haining
WN
,
Sarkar
S
,
Kalia
V
, et al
Molecular signature of CD8+ T cell exhaustion during chronic viral infection
.
Immunity
2007
;
27
:
670
84
.
29.
Shin
H
,
Blackburn
SD
,
Blattman
JN
,
Wherry
EJ
. 
Viral antigen and extensive division maintain virus-specific CD8 T cells during chronic infection
.
J Exp Med
2007
;
204
:
941
9
.
30.
Sen
DR
,
Kaminski
J
,
Barnitz
RA
,
Kurachi
M
,
Gerdemann
U
,
Yates
KB
, et al
The epigenetic landscape of T cell exhaustion
.
Science
2016
;
354
:
1165
9
.
31.
Philip
M
,
Fairchild
L
,
Sun
L
,
Horste
EL
,
Camara
S
,
Shakiba
M
, et al
Chromatin states define tumour-specific T cell dysfunction and reprogramming
.
Nature
2017
;
545
:
452
6
.
32.
Scott-Browne
JP
,
Ló Pez-Moyado
IF
,
Trifari
S
,
Wong
V
,
Chavez
L
,
Rao
A
, et al
Dynamic changes in chromatin accessibility occur in CD8+ T cells responding to viral infection
.
Immunity
2016
;
45
:
1327
40
.
33.
Bengsch
B
,
Johnson
AL
,
Kurachi
M
,
Odorizzi
PM
,
Pauken
KE
,
Attanasio
J
, et al
Bioenergetic insufficiencies due to metabolic alterations regulated by the inhibitory receptor PD-1 are an early driver of CD8(+) T cell exhaustion
.
Immunity
2016
;
45
:
358
73
.
34.
Zhang
L
,
Romero
P
. 
Metabolic control of CD8 + T cell fate decisions and antitumor immunity
.
Trends Mol Med
2018
;
24
:
30
48
.
35.
Barber
DL
,
Wherry
EJ
,
Masopust
D
,
Zhu
B
,
Allison
JP
,
Sharpe
AH
, et al
Restoring function in exhausted CD8 T cells during chronic viral infection
.
Nature
2006
;
439
:
682
7
.
36.
Wang
Y
,
Hu
J
,
Li
Y
,
Xiao
M
,
Wang
H
,
Tian
Q
, et al
The transcription factor TCF1 preserves the effector function of exhausted CD8 T cells during chronic viral infection
.
Front Immunol
2019
;
10
:
169
.
37.
Jin
H-T
,
Anderson
AC
,
Tan
WG
,
West
EE
,
Ha
S-J
,
Araki
K
, et al
Cooperation of Tim-3 and PD-1 in CD8 T-cell exhaustion during chronic viral infection
.
PNAS
2010
;
107
:
14733
8
.
38.
Wieland
D
,
Kemming
J
,
Schuch
A
,
Emmerich
F
,
Knolle
P
,
Neumann-Haefelin
C
, et al
TCF1+ hepatitis C virus-specific CD8+ T cells are maintained after cessation of chronic antigen stimulation
.
Nat Commun
2017
;
8
:
15050
.
39.
Wherry
EJ
,
Barber
DL
,
Kaech
SM
,
Blattman
JN
,
Ahmed
R
. 
Antigen-independent memory CD8 T cells do not develop during chronic viral infection
.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A
2004
;
101
:
16004
9
.
40.
Dow
C
,
Henderson
R
,
Sette
A
,
Mothé
BR
. 
CD4+ T-cell inhibitory ligands: a tool for characterizing dysfunctional CD4+ T cells during chronic infection
.
Immunology
2013
;
140
:
61
9
.
41.
Aubert
RD
,
Kamphorst
AO
,
Sarkar
S
,
Vezys
V
,
Ha
SJ
,
Barber
DL
, et al
Antigen-specific CD4 T-cell help rescues exhausted CD8 T cells during chronic viral infection
.
PNAS
2011
;
108
:
21182
7
.
42.
Crawford
A
,
Angelosanto
JM
,
Kao
C
,
Doering
TA
,
Odorizzi
PM
,
Barnett
BE
, et al
Molecular and transcriptional basis of CD4+ T cell dysfunction during chronic infection
.
Immunity
2014
;
40
:
289
302
.
43.
Kasprowicz
V
,
Schulze zur Wiesch
J
,
Kuntzen
T
,
Nolan
BE
,
Longworth
S
,
Berical
A
, et al
High Level of PD-1 expression on hepatitis C virus (HCV)-specific CD8+ and CD4+ T cells during acute HCV infection, irrespective of clinical outcome
.
J Virol
2008
;
82
:
3154
60
.
44.
Noyan
K
,
Nguyen
S
,
Betts
MR
,
Sönnerborg
A
,
Buggert
M
. 
Human immunodeficiency virus type-1 elite controllers maintain low co-expression of inhibitory receptors on CD4+ T cells
.
Front Immunol
2018
;
9
:
19
.
45.
Hwang
SJ
,
Cobb
DA
,
Bhadra
R
,
Youngblood
B
,
Khan
IA
. 
Blimp-1-mediated CD4 T cell exhaustion causes CD8 T cell dysfunction during chronic toxoplasmosis
.
J Exp Med
2016
;
213
:
1799
818
.
46.
Raziorrouh
B
,
Ulsenheimer
A
,
Schraut
W
,
Heeg
M
,
Kurktschiev
P
,
Zachoval
R
, et al
Inhibitory molecules that regulate expansion and restoration of HCV-specific CD4+ T cells in patients with chronic infection
.
Gastroenterology
2011
;
141
:
1422
31
.
47.
Xiao
W
,
Jiang
LF
,
Deng
XZ
,
Zhu
DY
,
Pei
JP
,
Xu
ML
, et al
PD-1/PD-L1 signal pathway participates in HCV F protein-induced T cell dysfunction in chronic HCV infection
.
Immunol Res
2016
;
64
:
412
23
.
48.
Jacobi
FJ
,
Wild
K
,
Smits
M
,
Zoldan
K
,
Csernalabics
B
,
Flecken
T
, et al
OX40 stimulation and PD-L1 blockade synergistically augment HBV-specific CD4 T cells in patients with HBeAg-negative infection
.
J Hepatol
2019
;
70
:
1103
13
.
49.
Raziorrouh
B
,
Heeg
M
,
Kurktschiev
P
,
Schraut
W
,
Zachoval
R
,
Wendtner
C
, et al
Inhibitory phenotype of HBV-specific CD4+ T-cells is characterized by high PD-1 expression but absent coregulation of multiple inhibitory molecules
.
PLoS One
2014
;
9
:
7
9
.
50.
Barathan
M
,
Gopal
K
,
Mohamed
R
,
Ellegård
R
,
Saeidi
A
,
Vadivelu
J
, et al
Chronic hepatitis C virus infection triggers spontaneous differential expression of biosignatures associated with T cell exhaustion and apoptosis signaling in peripheral blood mononucleocytes
.
Apoptosis
2015
;
20
:
466
80
.
51.
Nebbia
G
,
Peppa
D
,
Schurich
A
,
Khanna
P
,
Singh
HD
,
Cheng
Y
, et al
Upregulation of the Tim-3/Galectin-9 pathway of T cell exhaustion in chronic hepatitis B virus infection
.
PLoS One
2012
;
7
:
1
15
.
52.
Antoine
P
,
Olislagers
V
,
Huygens
A
,
Lecomte
S
,
Liesnard
C
,
Donner
C
, et al
Functional exhaustion of CD4 + T Lymphocytes during primary cytomegalovirus infection
.
J Immunol
2012
;
189
:
2665
72
.
53.
Vingert
B
,
Benati
D
,
Lambotte
O
,
de Truchis
P
,
Slama
L
,
Jeannin
P
, et al
HIV controllers maintain a population of highly efficient Th1 effector cells in contrast to patients treated in the long term
.
J Virol
2012
;
86
:
10661
74
.
54.
Kaufmann
DE
,
Kavanagh
DG
,
Pereyra
F
,
Zaunders
JJ
,
Mackey
EW
,
Miura
T
, et al
Upregulation of CTLA-4 by HIV-specific CD4+ T cells correlates with disease progression and defines a reversible immune dysfunction
.
Nat Immunol
2007
;
8
:
1246
54
.
55.
Jones
RB
,
Ndhlovu
LC
,
Barbour
JD
,
Sheth
PM
,
Jha
AR
,
Long
BR
, et al
Tim-3 expression defines a novel population of dysfunctional T cells with highly elevated frequencies in progressive HIV-1 infection
.
J Exp Med
2008
;
205
:
2763
79
.
56.
Wu
W
,
Shi
Y
,
Li
J
,
Chen
F
,
Chen
Z
,
Zheng
M
. 
Tim-3 expression on peripheral T cell subsets correlates with disease progression in hepatitis B infection
.
Virol J
2011
;
8
:
1
9
.
57.
Rallón
N
,
García
M
,
García-Samaniego
J
,
Cabello
A
,
Álvarez
B
,
Restrepo
C
, et al
Expression of PD-1 and tim-3 markers of T-cell exhaustion is associated with CD4 dynamics during the course of untreated and treated HIV infection
.
PLoS One
2018
;
13
:
1
14
.
58.
Popescu
I
,
Drummond
MB
,
Gama
L
,
Lambert
A
,
Hoji
A
,
Coon
T
, et al
HIV suppression restores the lung mucosal CD4+ T-cell viral immune response and resolves CD8+ T-cell alveolitis in patients at risk for HIV-associated chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
.
J Infect Dis
2016
;
214
:
1520
30
.
59.
Reiley
WW
,
Shafiani
S
,
Wittmer
ST
,
Tucker-Heard
G
,
Moon
JJ
,
Jenkins
MK
, et al
Distinct functions of antigen-specific CD4 T cells during murine Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection
.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A
2010
;
107
:
19408
13
.
60.
Clouthier
DL
,
Zhou
AC
,
Wortzman
ME
,
Luft
O
,
Levy
GA
,
Watts
TH
. 
GITR intrinsically sustains early type 1 and late follicular helper CD4 T cell accumulation to control a chronic viral infection
.
PLoS Pathog
2015
;
11
;
1
21
.
61.
Brooks
DG
,
Teyton
L
,
Oldstone
MBA
,
McGavern
DB
. 
Intrinsic functional dysregulation of CD4 T cells occurs rapidly following persistent viral infection
.
J Virol
2005
;
79
;
10514
27
.
62.
Zinselmeyer
BH
,
Heydari
S
,
Sacristán
C
,
Nayak
D
,
Cammer
M
,
Herz
J
, et al
PD-1 promotes immune exhaustion by inducing antiviral T cell motility paralysis
.
J Exp Med
2013
;
210
:
757
74
.
63.
Perreau
M
,
Vigano
S
,
Bellanger
F
,
Pellaton
C
,
Buss
G
,
Comte
D
, et al
Exhaustion of bacteria-specific CD4 T cells and microbial translocation in common variable immunodeficiency disorders
.
J Exp Med
2014
;
211
:
2033
45
.
64.
Beyer
M
,
Abdullah
Z
,
Chemnitz
JM
,
Maisel
D
,
Sander
J
,
Lehmann
C
, et al
Tumor-necrosis factor impairs CD4+ T cell-mediated immunological control in chronic viral infection
.
Nat Immunol
2016
;
17
:
593
603
.
65.
Luft
O
,
Khattar
R
,
Farrokhi
K
,
Ferri
D
,
Yavorska
N
,
Zhang
J
, et al
Inhibition of the fibrinogen-like protein 2:FcγRIIB/RIII immunosuppressive pathway enhances antiviral T-cell and B-cell responses leading to clearance of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus clone 13
.
Immunology
2018
;
154
:
476
89
.
66.
Snell
LM
,
Osokine
I
,
Yamada
DH
,
De la Fuente
JR
,
Elsaesser
HJ
,
Brooks
DG
. 
Overcoming CD4 Th1 cell fate restrictions to sustain antiviral CD8 T cells and control persistent virus infection
.
Cell Rep
2016
;
16
:
3286
96
.
67.
Foldi
J
,
Kozhaya
L
,
McCarty
B
,
Mwamzuka
M
,
Marshed
F
,
Ilmet
T
, et al
HIV-infected children have elevated levels of PD-1+ memory CD4 T cells with low proliferative capacity and high inflammatory cytokine effector functions
.
J Infect Dis
2017
;
216
:
641
50
.
68.
Esch
KJ
,
Juelsgaard
R
,
Martinez
PA
,
Jones
DE
,
Petersen
CA
. 
Programmed death 1–mediated T cell exhaustion during visceral leishmaniasis impairs phagocyte function
.
J Immunol
2013
;
191
:
5542
50
.
69.
Maine
CJ
,
Teijaro
JR
,
Marquardt
K
,
Sherman
LA
. 
PTPN22 contributes to exhaustion of T lymphocytes during chronic viral infection
.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A
2016
;
113
:
E7231
E9
.
70.
Ciucci
T
,
Vacchio
MS
,
Gao
Y
,
Tomassoni Ardori
F
,
Candia
J
,
Mehta
M
, et al
The emergence and functional fitness of memory CD4 + T cells require the transcription factor Thpok
.
Immunity
2019
;
50
:
91
105
.
71.
Ames
RY
,
Ting
LM
,
Gendlina
I
,
Kim
K
,
Macian
F
. 
The transcription factor NFAT1 participates in the induction of CD4+ T cell functional exhaustion during Plasmodium yoelii infection
.
Infect Immun
2017
;
85
:
1
14
.
72.
Stone
SF
,
Price
P
,
French
MA
. 
Dysregulation of CD28 and CTLA-4 expression by CD4 T cells from previously immunodeficient HIV-infected patients with sustained virological responses to highly active antiretroviral therapy
.
HIV Med
2005
;
6
:
278
83
.
73.
Salwe
S
,
Singh
A
,
Padwal
V
,
Velhal
S
,
Nagar
V
,
Patil
P
, et al
Immune signatures for HIV-1 and HIV-2 induced CD4 + T cell dysregulation in an Indian cohort
.
BMC Infect Dis
2019
;
19
:
1
13
.
74.
Woroniecka
KI
,
Rhodin
KE
,
Dechant
C
,
Cui
X
,
Chongsathidkiet
P
,
Wilkinson
D
, et al
4–1BB agonism averts Til exhaustion and licenses PD-1 blockade in glioblastoma and other intracranial cancers
.
Clin Cancer Res
2020
;
26
:
1349
58
.
75.
Kim
K
,
Park
S
,
Park
SY
,
Kim
G
,
Park
SM
,
Cho
J-W
, et al
Single-cell transcriptome analysis reveals TOX as a promoting factor for T cell exhaustion and a predictor for anti-PD-1 responses in human cancer
.
Genome Med
2020
;
12
:
22
.
76.
Shi
F
,
Chang
H
,
Zhou
Q
,
Zhao
Y-J
,
Wu
G-J
,
Song
Q-K
. 
Distribution of CD4+ and CD8+ exhausted tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in molecular subtypes of Chinese breast cancer patients
.
Onco Targets Ther
2018
;
11
:
6139
45
.
77.
Ryan
N
,
Anderson
K
,
Volpedo
G
,
Hamza
O
,
Varikuti
S
,
Satoskar
AR
, et al
STAT1 inhibits T-cell exhaustion and myeloid derived suppressor cell accumulation to promote antitumor immune responses in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma
.
Int J Cancer
2020
;
146
:
1717
29
.
78.
Nair
VS
,
Toor
SM
,
Taha
RZ
,
Ahmed
AA
,
Kurer
MA
,
Murshed
K
, et al
Transcriptomic profiling of tumor-infiltrating CD4+ TIM-3+ T cells reveals their suppressive, exhausted, and metastatic characteristics in colorectal cancer patients
.
Vaccines
2020
;
8
:
71
.
79.
Mittal
R
,
Chen
CW
,
Lyons
JD
,
Margoles
LM
,
Liang
Z
,
Coopersmith
CM
, et al
Murine lung cancer induces generalized T-cell exhaustion
.
J Surg Res
2015
;
195
:
541
9
.
80.
Prado-Garcia
H
,
Romero-Garcia
S
,
Puerto-Aquino
A
,
Rumbo-Nava
U
. 
The PD-L1/PD-1 pathway promotes dysfunction, but not “exhaustion”, in tumor-responding T cells from pleural effusions in lung cancer patients
.
Cancer Immunol Immunother
2017
;
66
:
765
76
.
81.
Rad Pour
S
,
Morikawa
H
,
Kiani
NA
,
Yang
M
,
Azimi
A
,
Shafi
G
, et al
Exhaustion of CD4+ T-cells mediated by the kynurenine pathway in melanoma
.
Sci Rep
2019
;
9
:
1
11
.
82.
Tan
J
,
Chen
S
,
Huang
J
,
Chen
Y
,
Yang
L
,
Wang
C
, et al
Increased exhausted CD8 + T cells with programmed death-1, T-cell immunoglobulin and mucin-domain-containing-3 phenotype in patients with multiple myeloma
.
Asia Pac J Clin Oncol
2018
;
14
:
e266
e74
.
83.
Nakano
M
,
Ito
M
,
Tanaka
R
,
Yamaguchi
K
,
Ariyama
H
,
Mitsugi
K
, et al
PD-1+ TIM-3+ T cells in malignant ascites predict prognosis of gastrointestinal cancer
.
Cancer Sci
2018
;
109
:
2986
92
.
84.
Yuan
L
,
Xu
B
,
Yuan
P
,
Zhou
J
,
Qin
P
,
Han
L
, et al
Tumor-infiltrating CD4+ T cells in patients with gastric cancer
.
Cancer Cell Int
2017
;
17
:
1
12
.
85.
Allahmoradi
E
,
Taghiloo
S
,
Tehrani
M
,
Hossein-Nattaj
H
,
Janbabaei
G
,
Shekarriz
R
, et al
CD4+ T cells are exhausted and show functional defects in chronic lymphocytic leukemia
.
Iran J Immunol
2017
;
14
:
257
69
.
86.
Tang
L
,
Wu
J
,
Li
CG
,
Jiang
HW
,
Xu
M
,
Du
M
, et al
Characterization of immune dysfunction and identification of prognostic immune-related risk factors in acute myeloid leukemia
.
Clin Cancer Res
2020
;
26
:
1763
72
.
87.
Tan
J
,
Huang
S
,
Huang
J
,
Yu
Z
,
Chen
Y
,
Lu
Y
, et al
Increasing Tim-3+CD244+, Tim-3+CD57+, and Tim-3+PD-1+ T cells in patients with acute myeloid leukemia
.
Asia Pac J Clin Oncol
2020
;
16
:
137
41
.
88.
Solman
IG
,
Blum
LK
,
Hoh
HY
,
Kipps
TJ
,
Burger
JA
,
Barrientos
JC
, et al
Ibrutinib restores immune cell numbers and function in first-line and relapsed/refractory chronic lymphocytic leukemia
.
Leuk Res
2020
;
97
:
106432
.
89.
Rusak
M
,
Eljaszewicz
A
,
Bołkun
Ł
,
Łuksza
E
,
Łapuć
I
,
Piszcz
J
, et al
Prognostic significance of PD-1 expression on peripheral blood CD4+ T cells in patients with newly diagnosed chronic lymphocytic leukemia
.
Pol Arch Med Wewn
2015
;
125
:
553
9
.
90.
Blaeschke
F
,
Willier
S
,
Stenger
D
,
Lepenies
M
,
Horstmann
MA
,
Escherich
G
, et al
Leukemia-induced dysfunctional TIM-3+CD4+ bone marrow T cells increase risk of relapse in pediatric B-precursor ALL patients
.
Leukemia
2020
;
34
:
2607
20
.
91.
Dama
P
,
Tang
M
,
Fulton
N
,
Kline
J
,
Liu
H
. 
Gal9/Tim-3 expression level is higher in AML patients who fail chemotherapy
.
J Immunother Cancer
2019
;
7
:
1
7
.
92.
Tan
J
,
Yu
Z
,
Huang
J
,
Chen
Y
,
Huang
S
,
Yao
D
, et al
Increased PD-1+Tim-3+ exhausted T cells in bone marrow may influence the clinical outcome of patients with AML
.
Biomark Res
2020
;
8
:
1
9
.
93.
Shi
W
,
Yang
B
,
Sun
Q
,
Meng
J
,
Zhao
X
,
Du
S
, et al
PD-1 regulates CXCR5+ CD4 T cell-mediated proinflammatory functions in non-small cell lung cancer patients
.
Int Immunopharmacol
2020
;
82
:
106295
.
94.
Zhou
ZQ
,
Tong
DN
,
Guan
J
,
Tan
HW
,
Zhao
LD
,
Zhu
Y
, et al
Follicular helper T cell exhaustion induced by PD-L1 expression in hepatocellular carcinoma results in impaired cytokine expression and B cell help, and is associated with advanced tumor stages
.
Am J Transl Res
2016
;
8
:
2926
36
.
95.
Goods
BA
,
Hernandez
AL
,
Lowther
DE
,
Lucca
LE
,
Lerner
BA
,
Gunel
M
, et al
Functional differences between PD-1+ and PD-1- CD4+ effector T cells in healthy donors and patients with glioblastoma multiforme
.
PLoS One
2017
;
12
:
1
18
.
96.
Pirozyan
MR
,
McGuire
HM
,
Emran
AA
,
Tseng
H-Y
,
Tiffen
JC
,
Lee
JH
, et al
Pretreatment innate cell populations and CD4 T cells in blood are associated with response to immune checkpoint blockade in melanoma patients
.
Front Immunol
2020
;
11
:
372
.
97.
Formenti
SC
,
Hawtin
RE
,
Dixit
N
,
Evensen
E
,
Lee
P
,
Goldberg
JD
, et al
Baseline T cell dysfunction by single cell network profiling in metastatic breast cancer patients
.
J Immunother Cancer
2019
;
7
:
1
8
.
98.
Zhu
S
,
Lin
J
,
Qiao
G
,
Wang
X
,
Xu
Y
. 
Tim-3 identifies exhausted follicular helper T cells in breast cancer patients
.
Immunobiology
2016
;
221
:
986
93
.
99.
Blanco
G
,
Puiggros
A
,
Sherry
B
,
Nonell
L
,
Calvo
X
,
Puigdecanet
E
, et al
Chronic lymphocytic leukemia–like monoclonal B-cell lymphocytosis exhibits an increased inflammatory signature that is reduced in early-stage chronic lymphocytic leukemia
.
Exp Hematol
2021
;
95
:
68
80
.
100.
Li
H
,
Wu
K
,
Tao
K
,
Chen
L
,
Zheng
Q
,
Lu
X
, et al
Tim-3/galectin-9 signaling pathway mediates T-cell dysfunction and predicts poor prognosis in patients with hepatitis B virus-associated hepatocellular carcinoma
.
Hepatology
2012
;
56
:
1342
51
.
101.
Rausch
MP
,
Hastings
KT
. 
An exhaustion-like phenotype constrains the activity of CD4+ T cells specific for a self and melanoma antigen
.
PLoS One
2015
;
10
:
1
14
.
102.
Malandro
N
,
Budhu
S
,
Kuhn
NF
,
Liu
C
,
Murphy
JT
,
Cortez
C
, et al
Clonal abundance of tumor-specific CD4+ T cells potentiates efficacy and alters susceptibility to exhaustion
.
Immunity
2016
;
44
:
179
93
.
103.
Wu
L
,
Mao
L
,
Liu
JF
,
Chen
L
,
Yu
GT
,
Yang
LL
, et al
Blockade of TIGIT/CD155 signaling reverses t-cell exhaustion and enhances antitumor capability in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma
.
Cancer Immunol Res
2019
;
7
:
1700
13
.
104.
Dubinski
D
,
Wölfer
J
,
Hasselblatt
M
,
Schneider-Hohendorf
T
,
Bogdahn
U
,
Stummer
W
, et al
CD4+ T effector memory cell dysfunction is associated with the accumulation of granulocytic myeloid-derived suppressor cells in glioblastoma patients
.
Neuro Oncol
2016
;
18
:
807
18
.
105.
Zhou
H
,
Liu
T
,
Wang
Z
. 
Analysis of non-small cell lung cancer microenvironment indicates preponderance of T cell exhaustion marker expression
.
Exp Cell Res
2017
;
360
:
205
9
.
106.
Oja
AE
,
Piet
B
,
Van Der Zwan
D
,
Blaauwgeers
H
,
Mensink
M
,
De Kivit
S
, et al
Functional heterogeneity of CD4+ tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes with a resident memory phenotype in NSCLC
.
Front Immunol
2018
;
9
:
1
15
.
107.
Fu
J
,
Yu
A
,
Xiao
X
,
Tang
J
,
Zu
X
,
Chen
W
, et al
CD4+ T cell exhaustion leads to adoptive transfer therapy failure which can be prevented by immune checkpoint blockade
.
Am J Cancer Res
2020
;
10
:
4234
50
.
108.
Balança
C-C
,
Salvioni
A
,
Scarlata
C-M
,
Michelas
M
,
Martinez-Gomez
C
,
Gomez-Roca
C
, et al
PD-1 blockade restores helper activity of tumor-infiltrating, exhausted PD-1 hi CD39 + CD4 T cells
.
JCI Insight
2021
;
6
:
e142513
.
109.
Sekine
T
,
Perez-Potti
A
,
Nguyen
S
,
Gorin
JB
,
Wu
VH
,
Gostick
E
, et al
TOX is expressed by exhausted and polyfunctional human effector memory CD8+ T cells
.
Science Immunology
2020
;
5
:
eaba7918
.
110.
Khan
O
,
Giles
JR
,
McDonald
S
,
Manne
S
,
Ngiow
SF
,
Patel
KP
, et al
TOX transcriptionally and epigenetically programs CD8+ T cell exhaustion
.
Nature
2019
;
571
:
211
8
.
111.
Catakovic
K
,
Gassner
FJ
,
Ratswohl
C
,
Zaborsky
N
,
Rebhandl
S
,
Schubert
M
, et al
TIGIT expressing CD4+T cells represent a tumor-supportive T cell subset in chronic lymphocytic leukemia
.
OncoImmunology
2017
;
7
:
e1371399
.
112.
Goding
SR
,
Wilson
KA
,
Xie
Y
,
Harris
KM
,
Baxi
A
,
Akpinarli
A
, et al
Restoring immune function of tumor-specific CD4 + T cells during recurrence of melanoma
.
J Immunol
2013
;
190
:
4899
909
.
113.
Goding
SR
,
Wilson
KA
,
Rosinsky
C
,
Antony
PA
. 
PD-L1–independent mechanisms control the resistance of melanoma to CD4 + T cell adoptive immunotherapy
.
J Immunol
2018
;
200
:
3304
11
.
114.
Lowther
DE
,
Goods
BA
,
Lucca
LE
,
Lerner
BA
,
Raddassi
K
,
van Dijk
D
, et al
PD-1 marks dysfunctional regulatory T cells in malignant gliomas
.
JCI Insight
2016
;
1
:
e85935
.
115.
Kalathil
SG
,
Wang
K
,
Hutson
A
,
Iyer
R
,
Thanavala
Y
. 
Tivozanib mediated inhibition of c-Kit/SCF signaling on Tregs and MDSCs and reversal of tumor induced immune suppression correlates with survival of HCC patients
.
OncoImmunology
2020
;
9
:
1824863
.
116.
Fecci
PE
,
Mitchell
DA
,
Whitesides
JF
,
Xie
W
,
Friedman
AH
,
Archer
GE
, et al
Increased regulatory T-cell fraction amidst a diminished CD4 compartment explains cellular immune defects in patients with malignant glioma
.
Cancer Res
2006
;
66
:
3294
302
.
117.
Andaloussi
AE
,
Lesniak
MS
. 
An increase in CD4+CD25+FOXP3+ regulatory T cells in tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes of human glioblastoma multiforme1
.
Neuro-oncol
2006
;
8
:
234
43
.
118.
Alonso
R
,
Flament
H
,
Lemoine
S
,
Sedlik
C
,
Bottasso
E
,
Péguillet
I
, et al
Induction of anergic or regulatory tumor-specific CD4+ T cells in the tumor-draining lymph node
.
Nat Commun
2018
;
9
:
1
17
.
119.
Abe
BT
,
Shin
DS
,
Mocholi
E
,
Macian
F
. 
NFAT1 supports tumor-induced anergy of CD4+ T cells
.
Cancer Res
2012
;
72
:
4642
51
.
120.
Fornara
O
,
Odeberg
J
,
Wolmer Solberg
N
,
Tammik
C
,
Skarman
P
,
Peredo
I
, et al
Poor survival in glioblastoma patients is associated with early signs of immunosenescence in the CD4 T-cell compartment after surgery
.
OncoImmunology
2015
;
4
:
e1036211
.
121.
Schietinger
A
,
Greenberg
PD
. 
Tolerance and exhaustion: Defining mechanisms of T cell dysfunction
.
Trends Immunol
2014
;
35
:
51
60
.
122.
Xia
A
,
Zhang
Y
,
Xu
J
,
Yin
T
,
Lu
XJ
. 
T cell dysfunction in cancer immunity and immunotherapy
.
Front Immunol
2019
;
10
:
1719
.
123.
Kasakovski
D
,
Xu
L
,
Li
Y
. 
T cell senescence and CAR-T cell exhaustion in hematological malignancies
.
J Hematol Oncol
2018
;
11
:
91
.
124.
Zhao
Y
,
Shao
Q
,
Peng
G
. 
Exhaustion and senescence: two crucial dysfunctional states of T cells in the tumor microenvironment
.
Cell Mol Immunol
2020
;
17
:
27
35
.
125.
Porrett
PM
,
Lee
MK
,
Lian
MM
,
Wang
J
,
Caton
AJ
,
Deng
S
, et al
A direct comparison of rejection by CD8 and CD4 T cells in a transgenic model of allotransplantation
.
Arch Immunol Ther Exp
2008
;
56
:
193
200
.
126.
Boisgérault
F
,
Liu
Y
,
Anosova
N
,
Ehrlich
E
,
Dana
MR
,
Benichou
G
. 
Role of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells in allorecognition: lessons from corneal transplantation
.
J Immunol
2001
;
167
:
1891
9
.
127.
Chen
Y
,
Heeger
PS
,
Valujskikh
A
. 
In vivo helper functions of alloreactive memory CD4 + T cells remain intact despite donor-specific transfusion and anti-CD40 ligand therapy
.
J Immunol
2004
;
172
:
5456
66
.
128.
Mcdonald-Hyman
C
,
Flynn
R
,
Panoskaltsis-Mortari
A
,
Peterson
N
,
Macdonald
KPA
,
Hill
GR
, et al
Therapeutic regulatory T-cell adoptive transfer ameliorates established murine chronic GVHD in a CXCR5-dependent manner
.
Blood
2016
;
128
:
1013
7
.
129.
Edinger
M
,
Hoffmann
P
,
Ermann
J
,
Drago
K
,
Fathman
CG
,
Strober
S
, et al
CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells preserve graft-versus-tumor activity while inhibiting graft-versus-host disease after bone marrow transplantation
.
Nat Med
2003
;
9
:
1144
50
.
130.
Taylor
PA
,
Lees
CJ
,
Blazar
BR
. 
The infusion of ex vivo activated and expanded CD4+CD25+ immune regulatory cells inhibits graft-versus-host disease lethality
.
Blood
2002
;
99
:
3493
9
.
131.
Lucas
F
,
Pennell
M
,
Huang
Y
,
Benson
DM
,
Efebera
YA
,
Chaudhry
M
, et al
T cell transcriptional profiling and immunophenotyping uncover LAG3 as a potential significant target of immune modulation in multiple myeloma
.
Biol Blood Marrow Transplant
2020
;
26
:
7
15
.
132.
Simonetta
F
,
Pradier
A
,
Bosshard
C
,
Masouridi-Levrat
S
,
Dantin
C
,
Koutsi
A
, et al
Dynamics of expression of programmed cell death protein-1 (PD-1) on T cells after allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation
.
Front Immunol
2019
;
10
:
1034
.
133.
Bettonville
M
,
D'aria
S
,
Weatherly
K
,
Porporato
PE
,
Zhang
J
,
Bousbata
S
, et al
Long-term antigen exposure irreversibly modifies metabolic requirements for T cell function
.
eLife
2018
;
7
:
1
24
.
134.
Liu
Y
,
Ji
H
,
Zhang
Y
,
Shen
XD
,
Gao
F
,
Nguyen
TT
, et al
Negative CD4+TIM-3 signaling confers resistance against cold preservation damage in mouse liver transplantation
.
Am J Transplant
2015
;
15
:
954
64
.
135.
Wu
J
,
Zhang
H
,
Shi
X
,
Xiao
X
,
Fan
Y
,
Minze
LJ
, et al
Ablation of transcription factor IRF4 promotes transplant acceptance by driving allogenic CD4+ T cell dysfunction
.
Immunity
2017
;
47
:
1114
28
.
136.
Sarraj
B
,
Ye
J
,
Akl
AI
,
Chen
G
,
Wang
JJ
,
Zhang
Z
, et al
Impaired selectin-dependent leukocyte recruitment induces T-cell exhaustion and prevents chronic allograft vasculopathy and rejection
.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A
2014
;
111
:
12145
50
.
137.
Raphael
I
,
Joern
RR
,
Forsthuber
TG
. 
Memory CD4+ T cells in immunity and autoimmune diseases
.
Cells
2020
;
9
:
531
.
138.
Chemin
K
,
Gerstner
C
,
Malmström
V
. 
Effector functions of CD4+ T cells at the site of local autoimmune inflammation—lessons from rheumatoid arthritis
.
Front Immunol
2019
;
10
:
353
.
139.
Koohini
Z
,
Hossein-Nataj
H
,
Mobini
M
,
Hosseinian-Amiri
A
,
Rafiei
A
,
Asgarian-Omran
H
. 
Analysis of PD-1 and Tim-3 expression on CD4+ T cells of patients with rheumatoid arthritis; negative association with DAS28
.
Clin Rheumatol
2018
;
37
:
2063
71
.
140.
Frenz
T
,
Grabski
E
,
Buschjäger
D
,
Vaas
LAI
,
Burgdorf
N
,
Schmidt
RE
, et al
CD4+ T cells in patients with chronic inflammatory rheumatic disorders show distinct levels of exhaustion
.
J Allergy Clin Immunol
2016
;
138
:
586
9
.
141.
Rangachari
M
,
Zhu
C
,
Sakuishi
K
,
Xiao
S
,
Karman
J
,
Chen
A
, et al
Bat3 promotes T cell responses and autoimmunity by repressing Tim-3-mediated cell death and exhaustion
.
Nat Med
2012
;
18
:
1394
400
.
142.
Liu
X
,
Wang
Y
,
Lu
H
,
Li
J
,
Yan
X
,
Xiao
M
, et al
Genome-wide analysis identifies NR4A1 as a key mediator of T cell dysfunction
.
Nature
2019
;
567
:
525
9
.
143.
Zhu
C
,
Sakuishi
K
,
Xiao
S
,
Sun
Z
,
Zaghouani
S
,
Gu
G
, et al
An IL-27/NFIL3 signalling axis drives Tim-3 and IL-10 expression and T-cell dysfunction
.
Nat Commun
2015
;
6
:
6072
.
144.
Swainson
LA
,
Mold
JE
,
Bajpai
UD
,
McCune
JM
. 
Expression of the autoimmune susceptibility gene FcRL3 on human regulatory T cells is associated with dysfunction and high levels of programmed cell death-1
.
J Immunol
2010
;
184
:
3639
47
.
145.
Zheng
H
,
Liu
X
,
Zhang
J
,
Rice
SJ
,
Wagman
M
,
Kong
Y
, et al
Expression of PD-1 on CD4+ T cells in peripheral blood associates with poor clinical outcome in non-small cell lung cancer
.
Oncotarget
2016
;
7
:
56233
40
.
146.
Satpathy
AT
,
Granja
JM
,
Yost
KE
,
Qi
Y
,
Meschi
F
,
McDermott
GP
, et al
Massively parallel single-cell chromatin landscapes of human immune cell development and intratumoral T cell exhaustion
.
Nat Biotechnol
2019
;
37
:
925
36
.
147.
Duraiswamy
J
,
Kaluza
KM
,
Freeman
GJ
,
Coukos
G
. 
Dual blockade of PD-1 and CTLA-4 combined with tumor vaccine effectively restores T-cell rejection function in tumors
.
Cancer Res
2013
;
73
:
3591
603
.
148.
Ozkazanc
D
,
Yoyen-Ermis
D
,
Tavukcuoglu
E
,
Buyukasik
Y
,
Esendagli
G
. 
Functional exhaustion of CD4+ T cells induced by co-stimulatory signals from myeloid leukaemia cells
.
Immunology
2016
;
149
:
460
71
.
149.
Mozaffari
F
,
Hansson
L
,
Kiaii
S
,
Ju
X
,
Rossmann
ED
,
Rabbani
H
, et al
Signalling molecules and cytokine production in T cells of multiple myeloma-increased abnormalities with advancing stage
.
Br J Haematol
2004
;
124
:
315
24
.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs International 4.0 License.