Environmental risk factors for uveal melanomas (cancer of the iris, ciliary body, and choroid) have not been identified. To search for these, we examined the correlation of age-adjusted eye cancer incidence rates, a surrogate for uveal melanoma rates, in U.S. states with group level geographic and demographic factors using multivariate linear regression. Incidence rates for eye cancer were inversely correlated with the percentage of the population receiving fluoridated water; that is, higher rates were found in states with lower prevalences of fluoridation (P = 0.01). Fluoride is known to inhibit the growth of microbial agents that cause choroiditis and choroidal lesions in animals. We speculate that fluoridation protects against choroidal melanoma by inhibiting microbial agents that cause choroiditis and/or choroidal lesions in humans. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev; 23(9); 1707–11. ©2014 AACR.

Melanomas of the uveal tract (iris, ciliary body, and choroid) are the most common primary intraocular cancer in adults. The vast majority of these affect the choroid, the pigmented, highly vascular layer of the eye between the sclera and the retina (1). Uveal melanomas are rare, with a mean age-adjusted incidence of 5.1 per million in the United States per year, but are sight- and life-threatening (2, 3). The case-fatality rate for uveal melanoma is approximately 50%, with most deaths due to liver metastases (4). An increased risk of metastasis is strongly associated with somatic mutations in the BAP1 gene located on chromosome 3 (5). Germline mutations in BAP1 cause hereditary predisposition to uveal melanoma in a subset of patients (6).

Little is known about the causes of uveal melanoma. Pathologically, uveal melanomas are believed to originate from neoplastic transformation of benign nevi (7). Host factors include light skin color, blue eye color, and an inability to tan (8). Arc welding is an established occupational risk factor (9, 10). Conversely, environmental risk factors for uveal melanoma have not been consistently identified. Unlike cutaneous melanoma, which is strongly associated with exposure to ultraviolet radiation, evidence for an etiologic role for ultraviolet radiation in uveal melanoma is weak (10, 11).

Historically, insights into cancer etiology often have come from ecologic (correlation) studies. Indeed, recognition of the association between cutaneous melanoma and exposure to ultraviolet radiation began with the correlation of cutaneous melanoma rates with geographic latitude (12). We sought to generate insight into the etiology of uveal melanoma by correlating eye cancer incidence rates in U.S. states with geographic and demographic features. We report that the incidence of eye cancer within the United States is correlated inversely with the availability of fluoridated water.

Uveal melanoma does not have a unique code in the International Classification of Diseases. However, because 90% of eye cancers in adults are ocular melanomas and the majority involve the uveal tract, adult eye cancer rates are commonly used as a surrogate for uveal melanoma rates (13). Data on eye and orbit cancer by state for 2006 to 2010 (for all ages) were obtained from the North American Association of Central Cancer Registries (NAACCR; ref. 14). Rates were age-adjusted to the 2000 U.S. Standard Population. Rates based on fewer than 10 cases were considered unstable and were censored. Because the incidence of uveal melanoma is rare among African Americans and is lower in Hispanic than in non-Hispanic Whites, we used data for non-Hispanic Whites only (15).

Data on latitude and longitude at the center of each state were obtained from netstate, an internet cartography website (16). Data on population density were obtained from the 2010 U.S. Census (17). Because the diagnosis of uveal melanoma requires ophthalmologic expertise, we examined the correlation between eye cancer incidence and the density of ophthalmologists. We calculated ophthalmologist density per state using the number of ophthalmologists per state as the numerator (available via U.S. News Doctor Finder; ref. 18) and the corresponding 2010 Census population as the denominator, multiplied by 100,000.

The state with the highest incidence of eye cancer, Oregon, has attracted public health attention due to the long-standing opposition of many Oregonians to water fluoridation (19). The U.S. Public Health Service endorsed water fluoridation to prevent tooth decay in 1951. However, the decision to fluoridate or not is made by municipal governments (20). To explore a possible relationship between fluoridation and eye cancer, we correlated eye cancer incidence rates with the percentage of the population of each state receiving fluoridated water in 2010. Fluoridation data were obtained from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC; ref. 21). The CDC tracks the number of persons receiving fluoridated water using a validated data system maintained in cooperation with the Association of State and Territorial Dental Directors (22).

Data were analyzed by multivariable linear regression using Excel. Variables considered to be potential confounders (e.g., latitude) were specified a priori or were identified empirically. Any factor with a P value of ≤0.10 was considered a potential confounder and was included in a final model. All statistical tests were two-tailed. P values ≤0.05 were considered significant.

Data on eye cancer that met NAACCR quality standards were available for 44 of 50 states. Data from Washington, DC were censored because of small numbers (N = 9). Age-adjusted incidence rates for eye cancer in the United States among non-Hispanic Whites in 2006 to 2010 ranged 4-fold and were lowest in South Dakota [0.29/100,000; 95% confidence interval (CI), 0.15–0.51; based on 13 cases] and highest in Oregon (1.23/100,000; 95% CI, 1.10–1.43; based on 242 cases). The average ophthalmologist density per state was 5.7 per 100,000 and ranged from 3.4 per 100,000 in Wyoming to 9.3 per 100,000 in New York. Access to fluoridated water ranged from 2.2% in Utah to >95% in several states.

Incidence rates for eye cancer were not significantly correlated with longitude, population density or ophthalmologist density (see Table 1). Incidence rates were modestly inversely correlated with latitude (i.e., were higher in sunnier states, P = .09) and were significantly inversely correlated with the percentage of the population with access to fluoridated water (P = 0.01; see Fig. 1). Only geographic latitude met our a priori criteria for possible confounding (P = .09). A multivariate model that included access to fluoridation and geographic latitude was highly significant (r = 0.45; P = 0.002).

Figure 1.

Scatter plot of incidence rates for eye cancer and the percentage of the population with access to fluoridated water in 2010.

Figure 1.

Scatter plot of incidence rates for eye cancer and the percentage of the population with access to fluoridated water in 2010.

Close modal
Table 1.

Correlation between the age-adjusted incidence rates of eye cancer in Whites 2006 to 2010 in U.S. states with geographic and demographic risk factors

VariablerP
Latitude 0.26 0.09 
Longitude 0.21 0.17 
Population density 0.06 0.70 
Ophthalmologist density 0.13 0.20 
Percentage receiving fluoridated water 0.38 0.01a 
Percentage receiving fluoridated water, model including latitude 0.45 0.002a 
VariablerP
Latitude 0.26 0.09 
Longitude 0.21 0.17 
Population density 0.06 0.70 
Ophthalmologist density 0.13 0.20 
Percentage receiving fluoridated water 0.38 0.01a 
Percentage receiving fluoridated water, model including latitude 0.45 0.002a 

NOTE: N = 44 for all correlations. NAACCR data for eye cancer were not available for Arkansas, Ohio, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Nevada, and Virginia.

aP ≤ 0.05.

Using population-based data on the incidence of eye cancer for 44 states, we observed an apparent protective effect of fluoridation; that is, states with greater access to fluoridated water had lower incidence rates for eye cancer. To our knowledge, this is the first report of an association between water fluoridation and eye cancer.

The lowest incidence rates for eye cancer were found in South and North Dakota (0.29/100,000; 95% CI, 015–0.51 and 0.41/100,000; 95% CI, 0.22–0.70, respectively). At least in part, this may reflect underdiagnosis in rural states. However, the correlation between eye cancer and access to fluoridated water was little influenced by these states, as censoring data for North and South Dakota did not meaningfully alter the correlation between access to fluoridation and eye cancer (r = 0.38 vs. r = 0.37, with and without the Dakotas, respectively). The state with the highest incidence of eye cancer was Oregon (1.23/100,000). It is noteworthy that a type of multifocal choroiditis occurs in Oregon. Watzke and colleagues described 10 patients with choroiditis that was identical to presumed ocular histoplasmosis, a choroidal disease thought to result from systemic infection with the fungus, Histoplasma capsulatum, which is prevalent in the United States, Ohio and Mississippi river valleys (23, 24). However, the Oregon patients were seronegative for Histoplasma and had not traveled to regions in which this fungus is endemic.

Eye cancer incidence rates were not significantly correlated with population density or with the density of ophthalmologists per state (P = 0.70 and 0.20, respectively). This suggests that detection bias is unlikely to play a major role in the variation in U.S. rates. We did not observe a significant correlation with either geographic longitude or latitude (P = 0.17 and 0.09). This finding is consistent with many reports, including a recent meta-analysis, which did not find a significant association between uveal melanoma and latitude at place of birth (10).

Our study has several limitations, including its ecologic design and biases caused by migration and misclassification. It is well known that correlations observed at the group level may not be observed at the individual level (25). Epidemiologic studies in individuals should obtain data on fluoride intake, including fluoride in diet, toothpastes, and mouthwashes (26). Because we do not know the latency period of uveal melanoma or the time period during which fluoride exposure may be important, these results are vulnerable to biases due to migration. However, because individuals at risk for eye cancer likely migrate for reasons unrelated to their disease, the effect of migration is likely to be nondirectional and would reduce the correlation between fluoridation and eye cancer.

The incidence rates for eye cancer from NAACCR were not stratified by age and include childhood cases. The major eye tumor of childhood, retinoblastoma, accounts for approximately 200 cases per year in Whites in the United States. As our analysis is based on >10,000 cases, retinoblastomas would contribute approximately 10% of the total. Because incidence rates for retinoblastoma are stable and do not vary geographically, any misclassification caused by their inclusion would bias our results toward the null (27). Some misclassification by other tumor types is likely. However, a detailed quality control analysis of NAACCR morphology data from 1995 to 1999 indicated that 70% of “eye and orbit” cancers were melanomas (28).

Conversely, this study has several strengths, including the use of high quality, incidence rates at the level of the state, and the novel use of validated data on access to fluoridated water. Fluoridation could illuminate several unexplained observations about eye cancer epidemiology. For example, eye cancer–related mortality rates (used as a surrogate for uveal melanoma incidence rates, as survival from uveal melanoma has not changed significantly in the past 50 years) in the United States were similar to eye cancer–related mortality rates in England and Wales in 1955 (29). However, mortality rates in the United States (but not the United Kingdom) declined >50% since then (30, 31). These trends are consistent with geographic trends in fluoridation, as only 10% of the UK currently receives fluoridated water (vs. ∼69% of the U.S. in 2006), and with temporal trends in the prevalence of fluoridation in the United States, which increased after 1951 (32, 33).

It is possible that the inverse correlation between access to fluoridated water and eye cancer incidence reflects a protective role for fluoride. Because fluoride has potent antimicrobial effects, a protective role would be understandable if uveal melanoma had a microbial origin. A viral etiology for uveal melanoma was suggested in 1979 but has received little support (34). In their discussion of histoplasma-like choroiditis in Oregon, Watzke and colleagues noted that in immunocompetent individuals, many microbial agents, for example, mycobacteria, could produce subclinical infections and chorioid lesions that heal spontaneously, leaving choroidal scars (23). This would explain the existence of “ocular histoplasmosis” in areas of the world in which histoplasmosis is not endemic. We speculate that in some individuals, choroidal lesions undergo malignant transformation. Thus, a tumor of the retinal pigment epithelium resembling uveal melanoma arising from a chorioretinal scar was described by Shields and colleagues (35). A choroidal melanoma regressing into a chorioretinal scar and recurring as a choroidal melanoma was described by Lambert and colleagues (36). Alternately, chorioretinal lesions have been described in association with infiltrating lymphocytes (37). Some infiltrating lymphocytes, for example, tumor associated macrophages, have potent immunosuppressive and angiogenic properties and are strongly associated with ocular carcinogenesis (38, 39).

We speculate that fluoridation protects against uveal melanoma by inhibiting microbial agents that cause choroiditis and/or choridal scars. Fluoride blocks metabolic enzymes required for the growth of bacteria and fungi (40, 41). Bacterial counts in fluoridated water are lower than in unfluoridated water (42). Fluoride prevents dental caries by inhibiting the oral bacterium, Streptococcus mutans (43). S. mutans and other bacteria potently induce choroiditis in non-human primates and in other experimental animals (44). For example, intracarotid injection of S. mutans causes choroiditis and chorioretinal scars in dogs (45). It would be valuable to use this model of choroiditis to examine the incidence of choriodal lesions in dogs given access to water with different levels of fluoride.

In summary, in this hypothesis-generating study, we observed that eye cancer incidence rates in U.S. states are inversely correlated with the availability of fluoridated water. If confirmed by analytic studies, this finding may be a productive clue to the enigmatic etiology of uveal melanoma (46).

No potential conflicts of interest were disclosed.

The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked advertisement in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.

1.
McLaughlin
CC
,
Wu
X-C
,
Jemal
A
,
Martin
HJ
,
Roche
LM
,
Chen
VW
. 
Incidence of noncutaneous melanomas in the U.S
.
Cancer
2005
;
103
:
1000
7
.
2.
Singh
AD
,
Turell
ME
,
Topham
AK
. 
Uveal melanoma: trends in incidence, treatment, and survival
.
Ophthalmology
2011
;
118
:
1664
78
.
3.
Pereira
PR
,
Odashiro
AN
,
Lim
L-A
,
Miyamoto
C
,
Blanco
PL
,
Odashiro
M
, et al
Current and emerging treatment options for uveal melanoma
.
Clin Ophthal
2013
;
7
:
1669
82
.
4.
Kujala
E
,
Makitie
T
,
Kivele
T
. 
Very long-term prognosis of patients with malignant uveal melanoma
.
Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci
2003
;
44
:
4651
9
.
5.
Harbour
JW
,
Onken
RD
,
Robertsen
ED
,
Suan
S
,
Cao
L
,
Worley
LA
, et al
Frequent mutation of BAP! In metastasizing uveal melanoma
.
Science
2010
;
330
:
1410
3
.
6.
Abdel-Rahman
MH
,
Pilarski
R
,
Cebulla
CM
,
Massengill
JB
,
Christopher
BN
,
Boru
G
, et al
Germline BAP1 mutation predisposes to uveal melanoma, lung adenocarcinoma, meningioma, and other cancers
.
J Med Genet
2011
;
48
:
856
9
.
7.
Weis
E
,
Shah
CP
,
Lajous
M
,
Shields
JA
,
Shields
CL
. 
The association of cutaneous and iris nevi with uveal melanoma: a meta-analysis
.
Opthalmology
2009
;
116
:
536
43
.
8.
Weis
E
,
Shah
CP
,
Lajous
M
,
Shields
JA
,
Shields
CL
. 
The association between host susceptibility factors and uveal melanoma: a meta-analysis
.
Arch Opthalmol
2006
;
124
:
54
60
.
9.
Guénel
P
,
Laforest
L
,
Cyr
D
,
Févotte
J
,
Sabroe
S
,
Dufour
C
, et al
Occupational risk factors, ultraviolet radiation, and ocular melanoma: a case–control study in France
.
Cancer Causes Control
2001
;
12
:
451
9
.
10.
Shah
CP
,
Weis
EW
,
Lajous
M
,
Shields
JA
,
Shields
CL
. 
Intermittent and chronic ultraviolet light exposure and uveal melanoma: a meta-analysis
.
Ophthalmology
2005
;
112
:
1599
607
.
11.
Sing
AD
,
Rennie
IG
,
Seregard
S
,
Biblin
M
,
McKenzie
J
. 
Sunlight exposure and pathogenesis of uveal melanoma
.
Surv Opthalmol
2004
;
49
:
419
28
.
12.
Lancaster
HO
,
Nelson
J
. 
Sunlight as a cause of melanoma: a clinical survey
.
Med J Aust
1957
;
6
:
452
6
.
13.
Foss
AJE
,
Cree
IA
,
Hungerford
JL
. 
Modelling uveal melanoma
.
Br J Ophthalmol
1999
;
83
:
588
94
.
14.
CINA+ online cancer in North America [Internet]. [cited June 1, 2014]
.
Available from
: http://www.cancer-rates.info/naaccr/
15.
Hu
DN
,
Yu
GP
,
McCormick
SA
,
Schneider
S
,
Finger
FT
. 
Population-based incidence of uveal melanoma in varous races and groups
.
Am J Opthalmol
2005
;
140
:
612
7
.
16.
Netstate.com [Internet]
.
[cited Jun 2, 2014]. Available from
: http://www.netstate.com/states/geography/al_geography.htm
17.
Bloomberg.com
. 
U.S. Population density: people per square mile U.S. census 1930 to 2010 [updated Dec 31, 2010; cited Jun 2, 2014]
.
Available from
: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-12-21/u-s-population-density-people-per-square-mile-u-s-census-1930-to-2010.html
18.
U.S. News Doctor Finder [Internet] U.S., news and World Report
.
[cited Jun, 2014]. Available from
: http://health.usnews.com/top-doctors/articles/2013/07/08/about-us-news-doctor-finder
19.
Foden-Vencil
K
. 
[Internet] National public radio shots: health news from NPR
.
Portland
,
Oregon becomes latest fluoride battleground
.
[cited Jun 2, 2014]. Available from
: http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2012/09/12/161003171/portland-ore-becomes-latest-fluoride-battleground.
20.
CDC
. 
Public health service report on fluoride benefits and risk
.
JAMA
1991
;
266
:
1061
7
.
21.
2010 Water fluoridation statistics [Internet] [updated December 31, 2010; cited Jun 2, 2014]
.
Atlanta, GA
:
Centers for disease control and prevention
.
Available from
: http://www.cdc.gov/fluoridation/statistics/2010stats.htm
22.
CDC
. 
Populations receiving optimally fluoridated public drinking water—United States, 1992–2006
.
MMWR
2008
;
57
:
737
41
.
23.
Watzke
RC
,
Klein
ML
,
Weiner
MH
. 
Histoplasmosis-like choroiditis in a nonendemic area. The Northwest United States
.
Retina
1998
;
18
:
204
12
.
24.
Oliver
A
,
Ciulla
TA
,
Comer
GM
. 
New and classic insights into presumed ocular histoplasmosis syndrome and its treatment
.
Curr Opin Opthalmol
2005
;
16
:
160
5
.
25.
Robinson
WS
. 
Ecologic correlations and the behavior of individuals
.
Am Soc Rev
1950
;
15
:
351
7
.
26.
Levy
SM
,
Guha-Chowhury
N
. 
Total fluoride intake and implications for dietary fluoride supplementation
.
J Public Health Dent
1999
;
56
:
211
23
.
27.
Broaddus
E
,
Topham
A
,
Singh
AD
. 
Incidence of retinoblastoma in the USA: 1975–2004
.
Br J Ophthalmol
2009
;
93
:
24
7
.
28.
Athas
W
. 
Quality assessment of CINA deluxe, 1995–1999 morphology data
.
Springfield, IL
:
North American Association of Central Cancer Registries
; 
1994
.
29.
Singh
AD
,
Topham
AT
. 
Survival rates with uveal melanoma in the United States: 1973–1997
.
Opthalmology
2003
;
110
:
962
5
.
30.
Foss
AJE
,
Dolin
PJ
. 
Trends in eye cancer mortality among adults in the USA and England and Wales
.
Br J Cancer
1996
;
74
:
1687
9
.
31.
Keenan
TD
,
Yeates
D
,
Goldacre
MJ
. 
Uveal melanoma in England: trends over time and geographical variation
.
Br J Opthalmol
2012
;
96
:
1415
9
.
32.
Gibson-Moore
H
. 
Water fluoridation for some—should it be for all?
Nutr Bull
2009
;
34
:
291
5
.
33.
Whelton
HP
,
Ketley
CE
,
McSweeney
F
,
O'Mullane
DM
. 
A review of fluorosis in the European Union: prevalence, risk factors and aesthetic issues
.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol
2004
;
32
(
Suppl 1
):
9
18
.
34.
Albert
DM
. 
The association of viruses with uveal melanoma
.
Trans Am Opthalmol Soc
1979
;
77
:
367
421
.
35.
Shields
JA
,
Eagle
RC
 Jr
,
Barr
CC
,
Shields
CL
,
Jones
DE
. 
Adenocarcinoma of retinal pigment epithelium arising from a juxtapapillary histoplasmosis scar
.
Arch Opthalmol
1994
;
112
:
650
3
.
36.
Lambert
SR
,
Char
DH
,
Hower
E
 Jr
,
Brawford
B
,
Wells
J
. 
Spontaneous regression of a choroidal melanoma
.
Arch Ophthalmol
1986
;
104
:
732
4
.
37.
Sheffer
A
,
Green
WR
,
Fine
SL
,
Kincaid
M
. 
Presumed ocular histoplasmosis syndrome
.
Arch Ophthalmol
1980
;
98
:
335
40
.
38.
Bronkhorts
IHG
,
Jager
MJ
. 
Inflammation in uveal melanoma
.
Eye
2013
;
27
:
217
23
.
39.
Jager
MJ
,
Ly
LV
,
Filali
ME
,
Madigan
MC
. 
Macrophages in uveal melanoma and in experimental ocular tumor models: friends or foes?
Prog Retin Eye Res
2011
;
30
:
129
46
.
40.
Marquis
RE
,
Clock
SA
,
Mota-Meira
M
. 
Fluoride and organic weak acids as modulators of microbial physiology
.
FEBS Microbiol Rev
2003
;
26
:
493
510
.
41.
Li
S
,
Breaker
RR
. 
Fluoride enhances the activity of fungicides that destabilize cell membranes
.
Bioorg Med Chem Lett
2012
;
22
:
3317
22
.
42.
Lalumandier
JA
,
Ayers
LW
. 
Fluoride and bacterial content of bottled water vs. tap water
.
Arch Fam Med
2000
;
9
:
246
50
.
43.
Loesche
WJ
. 
Microbiology of dental decay and periodontal disease
. In
Baron
S
(
editor
), 
Medical microbiology
, 4th edition,
Galveston, TX
:
NCBI Bookself
; 
1996
.
[cited Jun 1, 2014]. Available from
: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK8259/
44.
Meyers
SM
,
Rodrigues
M
,
Vasil
ML
. 
Fundus lesions after carotid injection of Streptococcus mutans in monkeys
.
Infect Immun
1982
;
35
:
1079
85
.
45.
Meyers
SM
,
Vasil
ML
,
Yamamoto
L
. 
Pathologic mechanisms of multifocal choroiditis with retinal detachment after carotid injection of Streptococcus mutans and other bacteria in dogs
.
Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci
1982
;
22
:
165
73
.
46.
Shields
CL
. 
The hunt for the secrets of uveal melanoma
.
Clin Exp Ophthalmol
2008
;
36
:
277
80
.