MHC-bound peptides from aberrant proteins may be a specific immunotherapeutic target on cancer cells. Because of difficulties in identifying such antigens, viral or model antigens have so far been used to study their biological relevance. We here identify a naturally existing human T-cell epitope derived from a truncated protein. The antigenic peptide is derived from the gene TTK only through an alternative transcript containing a premature termination codon that may target the transcript for nonsense-mediated decay (NMD). This antigen is recognized by HLA-A*02:01–restricted CD8+ T cells derived from an allotransplanted leukemia patient. Functional analyses showed that these T cells failed to recognize several HLA-matched primary leukemic cells that expressed the alternative TTK transcript. Conventional antigen processing and presentation were not affected, suggesting that leukemic cells modify the generation of antigens processed from aberrant proteins. This natural TTK epitope provides insights in the source of transcripts producing antigenic epitopes in healthy and leukemic cells. Our data underscore potential pitfalls of targeting NMD-derived or other unconventionally generated epitopes as immunotherapeutic approach.

The repertoire of HLA-presented peptides is dependent on antigen-containing protein expression and turnover. Therefore, translational events including premature termination of translation and protein misfolding are opportunities for regulation of antigen presentation. In tumor cells, protein production is often elevated, which is likely to result in increased premature termination and enhanced misfolding. The rapidly degraded subset of aberrant proteins is called defective ribosomal products (DRiP). The various classes of aberrant proteins are a potential source of (neo-)antigenic peptides and may provide specific targets for T-cell–based immunotherapy (1–4). This hypothesis is based on findings with viral and model antigens (5). In humans, natural T cells can recognize an antigen derived from an aberrant protein on insulin-producing β cells. These T cells may contribute to the induction of autoimmune diabetes (6). Similar responses may exist or be induced against natural antigens processed from aberrant proteins in tumor cells.

Donor lymphocyte infusion (DLI) after allogeneic stem cell transplantation (alloSCT) is an example of effective immunotherapy for the treatment of hematologic malignancies. The graft-versus-tumor effect of this therapy is mediated by allo-reactive donor T cells recognizing HLA-presented peptides, so-called minor histocompatibility antigens (minor H Ags), on the tumor cells. The immunogenicity of minor H Ags is a result of natural genetic variation between donor and recipient (7). Although donor T cells can mount potent responses against patient cells that carry minor H Ags, the transplanted cells (donor-derived and thus lacking minor H Ags) are spared (8, 9). Donor T cells may also attack healthy patient tissues causing graft-versus-host disease. Consequently, many studies have focused on the identification of new minor H Ags to understand how tissue-specific antigen presentation is controlled (10–12).

We now report the identification of a minor H Ag that is selectively encoded by an alternatively spliced transcript of the TTK gene. This transcript contains a premature termination codon leading to production of a truncated protein. The isolated T cells specific for this antigen fail to recognize the majority of leukemic cells expressing the alternative TTK transcript. The discovery of this antigen shows that leukemic cells, contrary to what is thought from model studies, are not necessarily immunogenic targets for T cells recognizing (neo-)antigens from aberrant proteins. Our data suggest that concern is warranted for immunotherapies targeting such antigens.

Cell samples, culture conditions, and isolation of T-cell clones

The CD8+ minor H Ag-specific cytotoxic T-cell (CTL) clones 10-4 and 10-5, designated as clone type H4, and here identified as recognizing LB-TTK-1D, were previously generated (13). T cells were isolated from a patient with myelodysplastic syndrome (patient 5852) who converted to 100% donor chimerism after treatment with alloSCT and DLI. T-cell clones were generated by single-cell sorting of HLA-DR+ CD8+ T cells by flow cytometry. T cells were cultured in IMDM supplemented with 5% FBS, 5% human serum, IL2 (100 IU/mL), and restimulated every 14 days with irradiated allogeneic peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) and phytohemagglutinin (0.8 μg/mL, Murex Biotec Limited). PBMCs and bone marrow mononuclear cells (BMMC) were obtained from patients and healthy individuals after approval by the Leiden UMC Institutional Review Board and informed consent according to the Declaration of Helsinki. Patients were HLA-typed using serologic analyses (n = 6) or DNA-sequencing (n = 9) by our HLA-lab that supports the allogeneic transplantation center. Mononuclear cells were isolated by Ficoll–Isopaque separation and cryopreserved. Phoenix Amphotropic Cells (Φnx-A; provided by Dr. J. Neefjes, The Netherlands Cancer Institute, Amsterdam, the Netherlands, 2013), HAP1 cells (provided by Dr. T. Brummelkamp, The Netherlands Cancer Institute, Amsterdam, the Netherlands, 2011), 2A14 melanoma cells (provided by Dr. S.H. van der Burg, LUMC, Leiden, the Netherlands, 2016), MZ1257 renal cell carcinoma cells (provided by Dr. B. Seliger, Johannes Gutenberg University, Mainz, Germany), fibroblasts (FB), keratinocytes (KC), EBV-transformed B cells (EBV-LCLs), CD40L-cultured B cells, PHA T blasts, and allo-HLA-A*02:01 reactive T cells (clone HSS12; ref. 14) were cultured as described previously (15–18). FB, KC, EBV-LCLs, and primary B and T cells were isolated and generated in our labs between 2005 and 2015. Cell lines were Mycoplasma negative as determined in bimonthly tests. Cell lines were not authenticated in the past year.

Whole-genome association scanning

Clone 10-5 was tested for recognition of 90 single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP)-genotyped EBV-LCLs by IFNγ ELISA. OD450 > 0.15 was considered to identify cells expressing minor H Ags. T-cell recognition was investigated for association with 1.1 × 106 SNPs by whole-genome association scanning (WGAs) using Fisher exact test as described previously (13).

1000 Genomes Project correlation analysis

Because haplotype blocks may differ per ethnic population (19) and because the original WGAs was based on minor H Ag phenotypes of Dutch individuals, we selected 1000 Genomes Project (1000GP) individuals of European descent for additional correlation calculations. We retrieved the genotypes for the highest associating SNP as identified by WGAs (rs608962) of 50 Caucasian (CEU) individuals from the 1000GP (20). The likely minor H Ag phenotype for each of those individuals was inferred from these genotype data and used to statistically determine which other SNPs on chromosome 6 (on which rs608962 is located) were in linkage disequilibrium with rs608962 (and thus also with the minor H Ag) using Fisher exact tests performed with our previously described and freely available algorithm in the software R (21). The top correlating SNPs were further analyzed for translational consequences using Ensembl GRCh38.p12 (https://www.ensembl.org). Peptide HLA–binding predictions were made using the NetMHC 3.2 server (22).

Tetramer staining

Cryopreserved PBMCs from patient 5852 obtained after alloSCT 6 weeks before (148 days after alloSCT) and 6 and 7 weeks after DLI (231 and 237 days after alloSCT) were thawed and stained with PE-conjugated UV-exchange tetramers containing LB-TTK-1D and APC-conjugated tetramers containing LB-ERAP1-1R. Tetramers were constructed as described previously (23, 24). Acquisition was performed on a FACS Calibur Analyzer (BD Biosciences) using CellQuest software and analyzed using FlowJo (Tree Star).

T-cell reactivity assays

Stimulator cells (5–15 × 103 cells/well) and T cells (2 × 103 cells/well) were coincubated overnight in 384-well plates. IFNγ release was measured by ELISA (Sanquin). To identify the antigenic epitope, peptides were synthesized, dissolved in DMSO, and pulsed at titrated concentrations in IMDM on EBV-LCLs from the stem cell donor, or on primary leukemic cells obtained from patients. After 2 hours of pulsing at 37°C, T cells were added, and IFNγ production in the supernatant was measured after overnight coincubation by IFNγ ELISA. T-cell recognition of healthy and malignant cells, which included PHA-blasts, CD40L-cultured B cells, dendritic cells, FB, KC, and leukemic cells of different origins (ALL, AML, CLL, and CML), as well as of donor EBV-LCLs either transduced with TTK-207 construct or a mock vector, was tested in a similar manner.

Genotyping of the SNP rs240226

To determine the genetic positivity for the LB-TTK-1D antigen, we performed genotyping of SNP rs608962 in intron 20 of TTK, which correlates with the minor H Ag encoding SNP rs240226 in European individuals of the 1000GP, using the KASPar SNP Genotyping System (KBioscience). The specific forward primers that were used for allele 1 and 2 were, respectively, 5′-GAAGGTGACCAAGTTCATGCTGTGTATTTACAATGGACTTATATTTTTCTTAT-3′, 5′-GAAGGTCGGAGTCAACGGATTGTGTATTTACAATGGACTTATATTTTTCTTAC-3′ and the shared reverse primer was 5′-TCTTCAGTGGTTCCCTTGGCCATTT-3′. Genomic DNA (10 ng) was amplified according to the manufacturer's instructions and fluorescent signals were quantified on a 7900HT device running with SDS Software (Applied Biosystems).

qRT-PCR

For qRT-PCR and sequencing analysis, tRNA was isolated using the RNAqueous Micro-Kit and Small Scale Kit (Ambion, Life Technologies) for a maximum of 0.5 × 106 and 10 × 106 cells, respectively, following the manufacturer's instructions. Fractionation of nuclear and cytoplasmic RNA was performed on 107 cells. Cells were lysed using a 0.05% NP-40 buffer (140 mmol/L NaCl, 1.5 mmol/L MgCl2, 10 mmol/L Tris–HCl, pH 8.0) containing 40 U/mL of RNAseOut (Invitrogen). After centrifugation, the nuclei (pellet) and cytoplasmic fraction (supernatant) were separated. RNA was then isolated using TRIzol and phenol–chloroform extraction, respectively. cDNA was synthesized from tRNA using Moloney murine leukemia virus reverse transcriptase (Invitrogen). For qPCR, TTK expression was measured on the Roche Lightcycler 480 using Fast Start TaqDNA Polymerase (both Roche) and EvaGreen (Biotium) with forward primer 5′-ACCTTACTGATGAACTAAGCTTGAA-3′ and reverse primer 5′-TCCCGAGTTATCTGTAGTATCAGC-3′ for the full-length TTK transcript and forward primer 5′-ACTTTGAATGGTGTCTGGCACA-3′ and reverse primer 5′-CTCTGGGTTGTTTGCCATCAT-3′ for the alternative TTK transcript. Expression was normalized to the PBGD (HMBS) reference gene.

Sanger sequencing of TTK-207

For Sanger sequencing of the alternative transcript TTK-207, we performed two sequential rounds of PCR on cDNA of patient EBV-LCLs using two primer sets each containing one primer that was specific for the alternative (and not the full-length) transcript. In the first round, forward primer 1 5′-ATGGAATCCGAGGATTTAAGTG-3′ and reverse primer 1 5′-TGTGCCAGACACCATTCAAAG-3′ as well as forward primer 2 5′-ACTTTGAATGGTGTCTGGCACA-3′ and reverse primer 2 5′-GTAGTCACGTGCATCATCTG-3′ were used to produce two products, which were combined to one fragment in the second round of amplification using forward primer 1 and reverse primer 2. The alternative TTK transcript was confirmed by Sanger sequencing in both directions.

Minigene cloning and transduction

A construct for the alternative TTK transcript containing exon 1-5 was cloned into a pLZRS vector containing a truncated ΔNGFR marker gene linked by an IRES. The construct was cloned from patient 5852 cDNA (homozygous for the minor H Ag encoding SNP) using a two-step PCR with forward primer 1 5′-CGCGGATCCACCATGGAATCCGAGGATTTAAGTG-3′ and reverse primer 1 5′-TGTGCCAGACACCATTCAAAG -3′ as well as forward primer 2 5′-ACTTTGAATGGTGTCTGGCACA-3′ and reverse primer 2 5′-TATATACTCGAGGTAGTCACGTGCATCATCTG-3′ in the first round to produce two bands, which were combined to one fragment in the second round of amplification using forward primer 1 and reverse primer 2. Fragments were digested with BamHI and XhoI for cloning and the transcript construct was confirmed by Sanger Sequencing. Retroviral supernatant was obtained by transfecting wild-type Φnx-A packaging cells as described previously (25) with the exception that the Fugene HD Transfection Kit (Roche) was used. Viral supernatant was used for transduction on plates coated with recombinant human fibronectin CH 296 (Takara Shuzo).

Genome-wide analyses identify the genetic locus of a minor H Ag

We previously isolated several T-cell clones specific for a single minor H Ag from a patient after alloSCT and DLI (13). In total, 14 clones using two different T-cell receptor variable β-chain (TRBV) recognized a minor H Ag with a population frequency of 50% in HLA-A*02:01. Because minor H Ags are polymorphic in the population, they can be identified using WGAs (13, 26, 27). Therefore, we first phenotyped 90 different EBV-LCLs by testing their individual capacity to activate the minor H Ag-specific T-cell clone 10-5 (Fig. 1A). Because we previously genotyped the same panel of EBV-LCLs for 1.1 × 106 SNPs, we next associated the minor H Ag phenotypes to these genotypes in a WGAs. This analysis identified 13 SNPs on chromosome 6 that associated with T-cell recognition (P < 3.0 × 10−16), of which the strongest associating SNP rs608962 had a P value of 3.6 × 10−20 (Fig. 1B). Although located in close proximity to and within the TTK gene, these SNPs were all noncoding and were therefore not our preferred candidates to encode the minor H Ag. Furthermore, Sanger sequencing of the primary transcript of TTK did not identify differences between patient and stem cell donor.

Figure 1.

Identification of associating SNPs in the TTK gene by extended whole-genome association scanning. A, Recognition of 90 individual EBV-LCLs (that were previously genotyped for 1.1 × 106 SNPs) was detected using T-cell clone 10-5. Each symbol indicates IFNγ production against one EBV-LCL as determined by ELISA after overnight coincubation (n = 1). Dashed line (OD450 = 0.15) is the cutoff used to discriminate cells that did or did not express minor H Ag. B, Manhattan plot showing the results of a conventional WGAs for clone 10-5 using a Fisher exact test. Minus logarithm of the P value of each SNP in the 1.1 × 106 genotypes dataset is plotted, each dot represents a single SNP. SNPs are plotted by their chromosomal location (x-axis). Only SNPs with a P < 10−1 are displayed. All SNPs associating with a P < 10−15 are shown in the inserted table. The strongest associating SNP rs608962 is located in intron 20 of the TTK gene. C, Results of an extended association analysis with SNP rs608962 for 50 European individuals (Fisher exact test). Minus logarithm of the P value of each SNP on chromosome 6 included in the 1000GP is plotted. Each dot represents a single SNP and is plotted on the basis of its physical location on chromosome 6. Only SNPs with P < 0.05 are shown. D, Zoom view of the area containing the significantly correlated SNPs on chromosome 6, showing a haplotype block including 93 SNPs that correlated for 100% within the 50 individuals used for this in silico analysis.

Figure 1.

Identification of associating SNPs in the TTK gene by extended whole-genome association scanning. A, Recognition of 90 individual EBV-LCLs (that were previously genotyped for 1.1 × 106 SNPs) was detected using T-cell clone 10-5. Each symbol indicates IFNγ production against one EBV-LCL as determined by ELISA after overnight coincubation (n = 1). Dashed line (OD450 = 0.15) is the cutoff used to discriminate cells that did or did not express minor H Ag. B, Manhattan plot showing the results of a conventional WGAs for clone 10-5 using a Fisher exact test. Minus logarithm of the P value of each SNP in the 1.1 × 106 genotypes dataset is plotted, each dot represents a single SNP. SNPs are plotted by their chromosomal location (x-axis). Only SNPs with a P < 10−1 are displayed. All SNPs associating with a P < 10−15 are shown in the inserted table. The strongest associating SNP rs608962 is located in intron 20 of the TTK gene. C, Results of an extended association analysis with SNP rs608962 for 50 European individuals (Fisher exact test). Minus logarithm of the P value of each SNP on chromosome 6 included in the 1000GP is plotted. Each dot represents a single SNP and is plotted on the basis of its physical location on chromosome 6. Only SNPs with P < 0.05 are shown. D, Zoom view of the area containing the significantly correlated SNPs on chromosome 6, showing a haplotype block including 93 SNPs that correlated for 100% within the 50 individuals used for this in silico analysis.

Close modal

During the last decade, we have improved the resolution of our genome-wide association strategy by implementing data of the 1000GP; containing more than 40 × 106 SNPs; refs. 21, 27, 28). We now used the 1000GP data for an in silico attempt to identify the encoding genetic variation of the minor H Ag as it could not be identified by the initial WGAs. We searched in the 1000GP data for coding SNPs that are in linkage disequilibrium with SNP rs608962 as identified by the WGAs to link with the minor H Ag encoding locus. The analysis yielded 93 fully correlating SNPs on chromosome 6 (Fig. 1C and D), of which only SNP rs240226 is a nonsynonymous coding variant, encoding a glutamic acid (E) to aspartic acid (D) change in a putative alternative TTK transcript.

The minor H Ag LB-TTK-1D is encoded by an alternative transcript

SNP rs240226 is located in an exon, found in an alternative TTK transcript (TTK-207, Ensembl) but absent from other TTK transcripts (Fig. 2A). TTK-207 contains a premature termination codon in the last but one exon, which may render this transcript susceptible to nonsense-mediated decay (NMD), and define its translational product as a DRiP (3, 29, 30). To show expression of this alternatively spliced transcript, we performed a two-step PCR strategy to amplify this transcript (illustrated in Fig. 2A, see Materials and Methods). Sanger sequencing of the amplified cDNA from patient EBV-LCLs confirmed that it was alternative transcript TTK-207. Because NMD transcripts have decreased expression in the cytoplasm compared with the nucleus (31), we separately analyzed expression of TTK-207 and the full length TTK transcript (TTK-201) in the nucleus and cytoplasm by qPCR. The data showed that the ratio of nuclear-to-cytoplasmic TTK-207 was higher than for TTK-201 in only one of the three cell lines tested (Fig. 2B). However, in all three cell lines, nuclear and cytoplasmic expression of TTK-207 was low compared with the full-length transcript, which is a characteristic of NMD-degraded transcripts (Fig. 2B; refs. 32, 33).

Figure 2.

LB-TTK-1D is encoded by alternative transcript TTK-207. A, Both full-length and alternative TTK transcripts are depicted. Coding (filled rectangles) and noncoding (white rectangles) exonic regions of the transcripts are shown. Introns are represented by black lines. Primer binding sites used for PCR and Sanger sequencing are shown in gray. A detailed view including translated amino acid code of the exon 3 in the alternatively spliced putative transcript TTK-207 is highlighted [sequence is localized in intron 2–3 of the full-length (FL; TTK-201) transcript]. SNP rs240662 (alleles T/G are bold) encodes an amino acid change from E in donor to D in recipient cells, suggesting RLHDGRVFV as the patient- (but not donor) expressed minor H antigen LB-TTK-1D, which is recognized by T-cell clone 10-5. B, cDNA was isolated from nuclei and cytoplasm of HAP1, 2A14, and MZ1257 cells and subjected to qPCR for alternatively spliced TTK-207 and full length TTK-201. Expression values were normalized against PBGD. Nucleus-to-cytoplasm ratios were calculated from the average of biological replicates (n = 2). C, Reactivity of clone 10-5 (gray bars) measured by IFNγ ELISA against patient and donor EBV-LCLs and donor EBV-LCLs retrovirally transduced with mock or TTK-207–expressing plasmids. The HLA-A*02:01–restricted USP11 peptide-specific T-cell clone HSS12 (14) was included as positive control (white bars; n = 2). D, Identification of the HLA-A*02:01–restricted epitope as recognized by TTK-specific T-cell clones 10-4 and 10-5. Synthetic peptides RLHDGRVFV or RLHEGRVFV, both predicted to bind to HLA-A*02:01 by NetMHC with a binding affinity <50 nmol/L, were titrated on donor EBV-LCLs and coincubated with T-cell clones 10-4 and 10-5. T-cell recognition after overnight coincubation was measured by IFNγ ELISA (n = 2). E, PBMCs from patient 5852 before (-6 weeks) and after (6 and 7 weeks) DLI were stained with PE-labeled HLA-peptide UV-exchange tetramers for LB-TTK-1D and APC-labeled HLA-peptide tetramers for LB-ERAP-1R. Numbers indicate the percentage of cells that are positive for the specific tetramer within the lymphocyte gate (n = 1).

Figure 2.

LB-TTK-1D is encoded by alternative transcript TTK-207. A, Both full-length and alternative TTK transcripts are depicted. Coding (filled rectangles) and noncoding (white rectangles) exonic regions of the transcripts are shown. Introns are represented by black lines. Primer binding sites used for PCR and Sanger sequencing are shown in gray. A detailed view including translated amino acid code of the exon 3 in the alternatively spliced putative transcript TTK-207 is highlighted [sequence is localized in intron 2–3 of the full-length (FL; TTK-201) transcript]. SNP rs240662 (alleles T/G are bold) encodes an amino acid change from E in donor to D in recipient cells, suggesting RLHDGRVFV as the patient- (but not donor) expressed minor H antigen LB-TTK-1D, which is recognized by T-cell clone 10-5. B, cDNA was isolated from nuclei and cytoplasm of HAP1, 2A14, and MZ1257 cells and subjected to qPCR for alternatively spliced TTK-207 and full length TTK-201. Expression values were normalized against PBGD. Nucleus-to-cytoplasm ratios were calculated from the average of biological replicates (n = 2). C, Reactivity of clone 10-5 (gray bars) measured by IFNγ ELISA against patient and donor EBV-LCLs and donor EBV-LCLs retrovirally transduced with mock or TTK-207–expressing plasmids. The HLA-A*02:01–restricted USP11 peptide-specific T-cell clone HSS12 (14) was included as positive control (white bars; n = 2). D, Identification of the HLA-A*02:01–restricted epitope as recognized by TTK-specific T-cell clones 10-4 and 10-5. Synthetic peptides RLHDGRVFV or RLHEGRVFV, both predicted to bind to HLA-A*02:01 by NetMHC with a binding affinity <50 nmol/L, were titrated on donor EBV-LCLs and coincubated with T-cell clones 10-4 and 10-5. T-cell recognition after overnight coincubation was measured by IFNγ ELISA (n = 2). E, PBMCs from patient 5852 before (-6 weeks) and after (6 and 7 weeks) DLI were stained with PE-labeled HLA-peptide UV-exchange tetramers for LB-TTK-1D and APC-labeled HLA-peptide tetramers for LB-ERAP-1R. Numbers indicate the percentage of cells that are positive for the specific tetramer within the lymphocyte gate (n = 1).

Close modal

To establish whether the minor H Ag is derived from TTK-207, we cloned this transcript from minor H Ag+ patient cDNA and retrovirally introduced this construct into donor EBV-LCLs. T-cell clone 10-5 recognized donor EBV-LCLs upon retroviral transduction with the construct (Fig. 2C), confirming that this transcript encodes the minor H Ag (LB-TTK-1D). On the basis of NetMHC HLA-peptide–binding predictions (22), we hypothesized that epitope RLHDGRVFV was the most likely candidate to be recognized by clone 10-5 with RLHEGRVFV being the allelic variant. Indeed, T-cell experiments confirmed that RLHDGRVFV was potently recognized with picomolar affinity, while the allelic E-variant was not recognized (Fig. 2D). Of note, two different T-cell receptors (TCR) for LB-TTK-1D represented by T-cell clone 10-5 (TRBV3-1) and clone 10-4 (TRBV19) showed similar affinity for the peptide (Fig. 2D).

The antigenic peptide recognized by T-cell clone 10-5 is only encoded by TTK-207 and not by other TTK transcripts and is therefore exclusively derived from the truncated TTK protein. TTK is a protein kinase that plays a role in mitosis. It has a kinase domain that stretches from exon 14 into exon 20 and an N-terminal tetratricopeptide repeat domain in exon 3, which is required for its subcellular localization to kinetochores (34, 35). Both domains are absent in the truncated protein encoded by TTK-207, suggesting that this protein lacks a physiologic function. Because TTK-207 is a naturally occurring transcript variant, the antigen LB-TTK-1D represents a tool to study the behavior of T-cell antigens processed from aberrant proteins.

T cells specific for minor H Ag LB-TTK-1D were detectable after DLI

To investigate whether T cells specific for LB-TTK-1D can undergo priming and expansion in vivo, we analyzed the peripheral blood of the alloSCT recipient 6 weeks before DLI and 6 and 7 weeks after DLI with tetramers. The frequencies of LB-TTK-1D–specific T cells were compared with minor H Ag LB-ERAP1-1R–specific T cells, which were previously identified as immunodominant in the same patient after DLI (13). Both antigen-specific T cells were undetectable prior to DLI but were detected in similar numbers after DLI (up to 0.25% and 0.58%, of total lymphocytes, respectively; Fig. 2E). This indicated that an oligoclonal T-cell response against LB-TTK-1D was induced in vivo that was similar to an immunodominant control T-cell response.

Leukemic cells fail to present the antigen LB-TTK-1D

The production of unconventional proteins including DRiPs may be increased in uncontrolled proliferating cells. Therefore, we investigated whether cancer cells are better recognized by LB-TTK-1D–specific T cells in comparison with healthy cells. Primary leukemic cells as well as healthy cells from various hematopoietic lineages isolated from patients and healthy donors who were positive for HLA-A*02 and the minor H Ag allele were tested for T-cell recognition. Only one of 11 leukemic tumors was recognized by the LB-TTK-1D–specific T cells (Fig. 3A). Of the various regular hematopoietic cell types [PHA T cells, (im)mature dendritic cells, CD40L-activated B cells, EBV-LCLs, full PBMCs, and BMMCs], immature monocyte-derived dendritic cells, PBMCs, and BMMCs lacked the capacity to activate LB-TTK-1D–specific T cells (Fig. 3A). For the immature dendritic cells, this could be explained by a decreased efficacy in general antigen processing and presentation, because these cells also induced lower activation of a control HLA-A*02:01–restricted T-cell clone recognizing an USP11-derived peptide (Fig. 3B). In contrast, antigen processing and presentation of conventional antigenic peptides in the majority of leukemic cells was intact, because they triggered the USP11-specific T-cell clone (Fig. 3B). Moreover, leukemic cells exogenously loaded with the TTK peptide stimulated T-cell clone 10-5, further substantiating that the leukemic cells are, in principle, functional presenters of antigens (Fig. 3C). Furthermore, T cells specific for LB-TTK-1D and USP11 exhibited a similar affinity toward their cognate peptide when exogenously loaded on T2 cells or EBV-LCLs or (both in the range of 0.2–2 nmol/L), indicating that the lack of recognition of LB-TTK-1D on leukemic cells was not skewed by differences in peptide-sensitivity between the two T-cell clones (Fig. 2D; Supplementary Fig. S1; ref. 14).

Figure 3.

Leukemic cells are rarely recognized by LB-TTK-1D–specific T cells. Reactivity of TTK-specific T-cell clone 10-5 (A and C) and control USP11-specific T-cell clone HSS12 (B) against malignant and healthy hematopoietic cells of different origin or lineages was determined by IFNγ ELISA. All samples were HLA-A*02+ and the presence or absence of the LB-TTK-1D genotype is indicated by (+) or (-) per sample [7/11 of the (+) and 2/4 of the (-) samples were high resolution HLA-typed]. Samples included malignant hematopoietic cells of different origins (CLL, AML, CML, and ALL) as well as a cell line derived from one of the primary ALLs (ALL line GD); patient and donor EBV-LCLs and PHA T cells; and immature and mature monocyte-derived dendritic cells (moDC), B cells cultured on CD40L-expressing cells, PBMCs and BMMCs, all from third party healthy donors (n = 1). C, Six leukemic samples were preloaded with serial diluted TTK-peptide quantities as indicated before exposure to T-cell clone 10-5. nd, not done (n = 1). D, Recognition of the ALL cell line GD by TTK-specific T-cell clone 10-5 (gray bars) and control USP11 peptide-specific T-cell clone HSS12 (white bars) as determined by IFNγ ELISA of culture supernatants. The ALL cell line was untransduced, mock transduced, or transduced with a vector encoding the TTK-207 transcript control (n = 2).

Figure 3.

Leukemic cells are rarely recognized by LB-TTK-1D–specific T cells. Reactivity of TTK-specific T-cell clone 10-5 (A and C) and control USP11-specific T-cell clone HSS12 (B) against malignant and healthy hematopoietic cells of different origin or lineages was determined by IFNγ ELISA. All samples were HLA-A*02+ and the presence or absence of the LB-TTK-1D genotype is indicated by (+) or (-) per sample [7/11 of the (+) and 2/4 of the (-) samples were high resolution HLA-typed]. Samples included malignant hematopoietic cells of different origins (CLL, AML, CML, and ALL) as well as a cell line derived from one of the primary ALLs (ALL line GD); patient and donor EBV-LCLs and PHA T cells; and immature and mature monocyte-derived dendritic cells (moDC), B cells cultured on CD40L-expressing cells, PBMCs and BMMCs, all from third party healthy donors (n = 1). C, Six leukemic samples were preloaded with serial diluted TTK-peptide quantities as indicated before exposure to T-cell clone 10-5. nd, not done (n = 1). D, Recognition of the ALL cell line GD by TTK-specific T-cell clone 10-5 (gray bars) and control USP11 peptide-specific T-cell clone HSS12 (white bars) as determined by IFNγ ELISA of culture supernatants. The ALL cell line was untransduced, mock transduced, or transduced with a vector encoding the TTK-207 transcript control (n = 2).

Close modal

A cell line generated from one of the ALL samples was, similar to its primary tumor, not recognized by LB-TTK-1D–specific T cells, whereas regular antigen processing and presentation was sufficient to stimulate USP11-specific T cells (Fig. 3A and D). Retroviral introduction of the alternative TTK-207 transcript restored the capacity of this cell to stimulate LB-TTK-1D–specific T cells (Fig. 3D). These results show that the processing and presentation of LB-TTK-1D in this ALL cell line is not defective, but rather suggest a failure in leukemic cells to express the truncated TTK protein.

To determine whether the failure to express the truncated TTK protein could be explained by low expression of the alternative TTK-207 transcript, we quantified expression of TTK-207 as well as the full length TTK transcript by qPCR. In all cells tested, expression of the alternatively spliced TTK-207 transcript was lower compared with the regular TTK transcript, again indicating that TTK-207 may be rapidly degraded through the NMD transcript surveillance pathway (Fig. 4; refs. 32, 33). All tested leukemic tumors naturally expressed the TTK-207 transcript, at least as much as did EBV-LCLs, which were efficiently recognized by T-cell clone 10-5 (Fig. 3A and 4). In summary, these data suggest that leukemic cells have developed mechanisms to prevent aberrant protein expression and thereby antigen presentation from unconventional, possibly NMD-derived, transcripts.

Figure 4.

Leukemic tumors express both the alternative and full-length TTK transcripts. Expression of the alternative (filled symbols) and full-length (open symbols) transcripts of TTK in different hematopoietic malignant and healthy cell types (details in Fig. 3) was determined by qRT-PCR. Depicted is the expression in arbitrary units after normalization to the expression of the PBGD reference. Donor EBV-LCLs transduced with the TTK-207 plasmid were included as positive control for the transcript-specific qPCR (n = 2). All samples were positive for the LB-TTK-1D allele.

Figure 4.

Leukemic tumors express both the alternative and full-length TTK transcripts. Expression of the alternative (filled symbols) and full-length (open symbols) transcripts of TTK in different hematopoietic malignant and healthy cell types (details in Fig. 3) was determined by qRT-PCR. Depicted is the expression in arbitrary units after normalization to the expression of the PBGD reference. Donor EBV-LCLs transduced with the TTK-207 plasmid were included as positive control for the transcript-specific qPCR (n = 2). All samples were positive for the LB-TTK-1D allele.

Close modal

In this article, we report the identification of a naturally occurring antigen encoded by an alternatively spliced transcript. This transcript contains a premature termination codon leading to the production of a truncated protein. The antigen is a polymorphic peptide recognized by minor H Ag reactive T cells, propagated only after HLA-matched allogeneic transplantation. We identified the HLA-A*02:01–restricted minor H Ag LB-TTK-1D by combining multiple genetic analyses. Currently, 1000GP-based analyses provide the most power to identify polymorphic antigens. Here, this power was required to identify the antigen recognized by T-cell clone 10-5, because conventional WGAs failed to determine the antigenic epitope. The additional in silico strategy that we used here is likely to be also applicable for identification of other minor H Ags not previously identified using SNP arrays (36).

The antigenic peptide is encoded by the alternative transcript TTK-207. As TTK-207 contains a premature termination codon more than 50 nucleotides (namely 193 nucleotides) before the last exon–exon junction, it is supposed to be subjected to the surveillance mechanism of NMD leading to rapid mRNA degradation (29, 30, 32, 33). Despite its low expression, we confirmed the presence of the alternative transcript in various cell types, and demonstrated that the transcript is sufficiently expressed for efficient T-cell induction in vivo and T-cell recognition in vitro. There has been much debate about the intracellular location and timing of NMD and how much protein is actually produced by NMD transcripts (37, 38). Evidence from in vitro data using model antigens indicates that NMD transcripts lead to newly synthesized but dysfunctional proteins that are rapidly degraded via the ubiquitin–proteasome pathway (32, 39, 40). Recognition of LB-TTK-1D on EBV-LCLs was indeed partially abolished by the proteasome inhibitor bortezomib (Supplementary Fig. S2), indicating that the truncated TTK protein is processed via the canonical route of the ubiquitin–proteasome system.

DRiPs are presumably generated in the pioneering rounds of translation, and artificial DRiPs encoded by NMD transcripts produce peptides for MHC class I presentation (32, 39, 40). However, the contribution of DRiPs relative to stable mature proteins to the total pool of antigenic peptides remains unclear (2, 3, 37, 39). Our data provide evidence that naturally occurring alternatively spliced transcripts encoding aberrant proteins may be a relevant source of (neo-)antigens.

Epitopes originating from DRiPs may serve as neoantigenic targets for antitumor immunotherapeutic approaches based on model antigen and compound inhibition studies (1, 4, 32, 41). The repertoire of antigenic peptides on tumor cells would increase upon inhibition of the rapid degradation process of NMD. This is supported by the finding that broad inhibition of NMD resulted in production of neoantigens and induction of specific immune responses, leading to tumor rejection in vivo (4). Despite the fact that the TTK antigen can induce robust allogeneic CD8+ T-cell expansion, it apparently was not able to induce autologous T-cell immunity in the patient before stem cell transplantation, implying that aberrant proteins such as DRiPs are not necessarily a class of immunogeneic neoantigens. Furthermore, the TTK-derived antigen is naturally expressed and presented by healthy cells showing that presentation of unconventional antigens is not restricted to tumor cells. Moreover, our data show that leukemic cells fail to present the TTK antigen to allogeneic CD8+ T cells even though they were genomically positive for the antigenic allele, expressed the alternative TTK transcript, and displayed proper antigen processing and presentation. These results may be explained by a discrepancy between the presence of the alternative TTK transcript and expression or turnover of its truncated protein product in different cell types (42). Leukemic cells may regulate these processes to minimize immunogeneic antigen presentation possibly through suppression of immunoribosomes (43, 44). These data indicate that antigens from aberrant proteins such as DRiPs are not necessarily good targets in cancer immunotherapy.

Our approach for characterizing this minor H Ag may aid future epitope identification studies. Our observation that this endogenous antigen, derived from an aberrant protein, is only occasionally expressed on tumor cells suggests potential risks to DRiP-directed immunotherapeutic applications.

T. Mutis reports receiving commercial research funding from Genmab, Takeda, Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Onkimmune, Aduro, and Novartis. No potential conflicts of interest were disclosed by the other authors.

Conception and design: M.J. Pont, R. Oostvogels, H.M. Lokhorst, J.H.F. Falkenburg, T. Mutis, M. Griffioen, R.M. Spaapen

Development of methodology: M.J. Pont, R. Oostvogels, J.H.F. Falkenburg, T. Mutis, M. Griffioen, R.M. Spaapen

Acquisition of data (provided animals, acquired and managed patients, provided facilities, etc.): M.J. Pont, R. Oostvogels, C.A.M. van Bergen, E.D. van der Meijden, M.W. Honders, S. Bliss, M. Griffioen

Analysis and interpretation of data (e.g., statistical analysis, biostatistics, computational analysis): M.J. Pont, R. Oostvogels, C.A.M. van Bergen, E.D. van der Meijden, M.W. Honders, J.H.F. Falkenburg, M. Griffioen, R.M. Spaapen

Writing, review, and/or revision of the manuscript: M.J. Pont, R. Oostvogels, H.M. Lokhorst, J.H.F. Falkenburg, T. Mutis, M. Griffioen, R.M. Spaapen

Administrative, technical, or material support (i.e., reporting or organizing data, constructing databases): R. Oostvogels, M.W. Honders, M.L.M. Jongsma, M. Griffioen

Study supervision: M.J. Pont, H.M. Lokhorst, M. Griffioen, R.M. Spaapen

The authors would like to thank Michel Kester for the production of tetramers and Dr. Marieke von Lindern and Nurcan Yagci for expertise and technical assistance on the isolation of nuclear and cytoplasmic RNA. This work was supported by a NWO-VENI personal grant (016.131.047, to R.M. Spaapen) and by the Dutch Cancer Society (UL 2010-4748, to M. Griffioen).

The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked advertisement in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.

1.
Kim
WK
,
Park
M
,
Kim
YJ
,
Shin
N
,
Kim
HK
,
You
KT
, et al
Identification and selective degradation of neopeptide-containing truncated mutant proteins in the tumors with high microsatellite instability
.
Clin Cancer Res
2013
;
19
:
3369
82
.
2.
Anton
LC
,
Yewdell
JW
. 
Translating DRiPs: MHC class I immunosurveillance of pathogens and tumors
.
J Leukoc Biol
2014
;
95
:
551
62
.
3.
Yewdell
JW
,
Anton
LC
,
Bennink
JR
. 
Defective ribosomal products (DRiPs): a major source of antigenic peptides for MHC class I molecules?
J Immunol
1996
;
157
:
1823
6
.
4.
Pastor
F
,
Kolonias
D
,
Giangrande
PH
,
Gilboa
E
. 
Induction of tumour immunity by targeted inhibition of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay
.
Nature
2010
;
465
:
227
30
.
5.
Dolan
BP
,
Bennink
JR
,
Yewdell
JW
. 
Translating DRiPs: progress in understanding viral and cellular sources of MHC class I peptide ligands
.
Cell Mol Life Sci
2011
;
68
:
1481
9
.
6.
Kracht
MJ
,
van Lummel
M
,
Nikolic
T
,
Joosten
AM
,
Laban
S
,
van der Slik
AR
, et al
Autoimmunity against a defective ribosomal insulin gene product in type 1 diabetes
.
Nat Med
2017
;
23
:
501
7
.
7.
Goulmy
E
. 
Human minor histocompatibility antigens: new concepts for marrow transplantation and adoptive immunotherapy
.
Immunol Rev
1997
;
157
:
125
40
.
8.
Mutis
T
,
Goulmy
E
. 
Targeting alloreactive T cells to hematopoietic system specific minor histocompatibility antigens for cellular immunotherapy of hematological malignancies after stem cell transplantation
.
Ann Hematol
2002
;
81
:
S38
9
.
9.
Falkenburg
JH
,
van de Corput
L
,
Marijt
EW
,
Willemze
R
. 
Minor histocompatibility antigens in human stem cell transplantation
.
Exp Hematol
2003
;
31
:
743
51
.
10.
van Bergen
CA
,
van Luxemburg-Heijs
SA
,
de Wreede
LC
,
Eefting
M
,
von dem Borne
PA
,
van Balen
P
, et al
Selective graft-versus-leukemia depends on magnitude and diversity of the alloreactive T cell response
.
J Clin Invest
2017
;
127
:
517
29
.
11.
Griffioen
M
,
van Bergen
CA
,
Falkenburg
JH
. 
Autosomal minor histocompatibility antigens: how genetic variants create diversity in immune targets
.
Front Immunol
2016
;
7
:
100
.
12.
Spaapen
R
,
Mutis
T
. 
Targeting haematopoietic-specific minor histocompatibility antigens to distinguish graft-versus-tumour effects from graft-versus-host disease
.
Best Pract Res Clin Haematol
2008
;
21
:
543
57
.
13.
Van Bergen
CAM
,
Rutten
CE
,
Van Der Meijden
ED
,
Van Luxemburg-Heijs
SAP
,
Lurvink
EGA
,
Houwing-Duistermaat
JJ
, et al
High-throughput characterization of 10 new minor histocompatibility antigens by whole genome association scanning
.
Cancer Res
2010
;
70
:
9073
83
.
14.
Amir
AL
,
van der Steen
DM
,
Hagedoorn
RS
,
Kester
MG
,
van Bergen
CA
,
Drijfhout
JW
, et al
Allo-HLA-reactive T cells inducing graft-versus-host disease are single peptide specific
.
Blood
2011
;
118
:
6733
42
.
15.
Griffioen
M
,
Honders
MW
,
van der Meijden
ED
,
van Luxemburg-Heijs
SA
,
Lurvink
EG
,
Kester
MG
, et al
Identification of 4 novel HLA-B*40:01 restricted minor histocompatibility antigens and their potential as targets for graft-versus-leukemia reactivity
.
Haematologica
2012
;
97
:
1196
204
.
16.
Jahn
L
,
Hombrink
P
,
Hassan
C
,
Kester
MG
,
van der Steen
DM
,
Hagedoorn
RS
, et al
Therapeutic targeting of the BCR-associated protein CD79b in a TCR-based approach is hampered by aberrant expression of CD79b
.
Blood
2015
;
125
:
949
58
.
17.
Jahn
L
,
Hombrink
P
,
Hagedoorn
RS
,
Kester
MG
,
van der Steen
DM
,
Rodriguez
T
, et al
TCR-based therapy for multiple myeloma and other B-cell malignancies targeting intracellular transcription factor BOB1
.
Blood
2017
;
129
:
1284
95
.
18.
van Asten
SD
,
Raaben
M
,
Nota
B
,
Spaapen
RM
. 
Secretome screening reveals fibroblast growth factors as novel inhibitors of viral replication
.
J Virol
2018
;
92
:
pii: e00260-18
.
19.
Stumpf
MP
. 
Haplotype diversity and the block structure of linkage disequilibrium
.
Trends Genet
2002
;
18
:
226
8
.
20.
Genomes Project
C
,
Abecasis
GR
,
Auton
A
,
Brooks
LD
,
DePristo
MA
,
Durbin
RM
, et al
An integrated map of genetic variation from 1,092 human genomes
.
Nature
2012
;
491
:
56
65
.
21.
Oostvogels
R
,
Lokhorst
HM
,
Minnema
MC
,
van Elk
M
,
van den Oudenalder
K
,
Spierings
E
, et al
Identification of minor histocompatibility antigens based on the 1000 Genomes Project
.
Haematologica
2014
;
99
:
1854
9
.
22.
Lundegaard
C
,
Lund
O
,
Nielsen
M
. 
Prediction of epitopes using neural network based methods
.
J Immunol Methods
2011
;
374
:
26
34
.
23.
Burrows
SR
,
Kienzle
N
,
Winterhalter
A
,
Bharadwaj
M
,
Altman
JD
,
Brooks
A
. 
Peptide-MHC class I tetrameric complexes display exquisite ligand specificity
.
J Immunol
2000
;
165
:
6229
34
.
24.
Rodenko
B
,
Toebes
M
,
Hadrup
SR
,
van Esch
WJ
,
Molenaar
AM
,
Schumacher
TN
, et al
Generation of peptide-MHC class I complexes through UV-mediated ligand exchange
.
Nat Protoc
2006
;
1
:
1120
32
.
25.
Griffioen
M
,
van Egmond
HM
,
Barnby-Porritt
H
,
van der Hoorn
MA
,
Hagedoorn
RS
,
Kester
MG
, et al
Genetic engineering of virus-specific T cells with T-cell receptors recognizing minor histocompatibility antigens for clinical application
.
Haematologica
2008
;
93
:
1535
43
.
26.
Pont
MJ
,
van der Lee
DI
,
van der Meijden
ED
,
van Bergen
CA
,
Kester
MG
,
Honders
MW
, et al
Integrated whole genome and transcriptome analysis identified a therapeutic minor histocompatibility antigen in a splice variant of ITGB2
.
Clin Cancer Res
2016
;
22
:
4185
96
.
27.
Spaapen
RM
,
de Kort
RA
,
van den Oudenalder
K
,
van Elk
M
,
Bloem
AC
,
Lokhorst
HM
, et al
Rapid identification of clinical relevant minor histocompatibility antigens via genome-wide zygosity-genotype correlation analysis
.
Clin Cancer Res
2009
;
15
:
7137
43
.
28.
Spaapen
RM
,
Lokhorst
HM
,
van den Oudenalder
K
,
Otterud
BE
,
Dolstra
H
,
Leppert
MF
, et al
Toward targeting B cell cancers with CD4+ CTLs: identification of a CD19-encoded minor histocompatibility antigen using a novel genome-wide analysis
.
J Exp Med
2008
;
205
:
2863
72
.
29.
Zerbino
DR
,
Achuthan
P
,
Akanni
W
,
Amode
MR
,
Barrell
D
,
Bhai
J
, et al
Ensembl 2018
.
Nucleic Acids Res
2018
;
46
:
D754
D61
.
30.
Nagy
E
,
Maquat
LE
. 
A rule for termination-codon position within intron-containing genes: when nonsense affects RNA abundance
.
Trends Biochem Sci
1998
;
23
:
198
9
.
31.
Chen
L
. 
A global comparison between nuclear and cytosolic transcriptomes reveals differential compartmentalization of alternative transcript isoforms
.
Nucleic Acids Res
2010
;
38
:
1086
97
.
32.
Chang
YF
,
Imam
JS
,
Wilkinson
MF
. 
The nonsense-mediated decay RNA surveillance pathway
.
Ann Rev Biochem
2007
;
76
:
51
74
.
33.
Rebbapragada
I
,
Lykke-Andersen
J
. 
Execution of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay: what defines a substrate?
Curr Opin Cell Biol
2009
;
21
:
394
402
.
34.
Pachis
ST
,
Kops
G
. 
Leader of the SAC: molecular mechanisms of Mps1/TTK regulation in mitosis
.
Open Biol
2018
;
8
:
pii: 180109
.
35.
Nijenhuis
W
,
von Castelmur
E
,
Littler
D
,
De Marco
V
,
Tromer
E
,
Vleugel
M
, et al
A TPR domain-containing N-terminal module of MPS1 is required for its kinetochore localization by Aurora B
.
J Cell Biol
2013
;
201
:
217
31
.
36.
Van Bergen
CA
,
Rutten
CE
,
Van Der Meijden
ED
,
Van Luxemburg-Heijs
SA
,
Lurvink
EG
,
Houwing-Duistermaat
JJ
, et al
High-throughput characterization of 10 new minor histocompatibility antigens by whole genome association scanning
.
Cancer Res
2010
;
70
:
9073
83
.
37.
Rock
KL
,
Farfan-Arribas
DJ
,
Colbert
JD
,
Goldberg
AL
. 
Re-examining class-I presentation and the DRiP hypothesis
.
Trends Immunol
2014
;
35
:
144
52
.
38.
Apcher
S
,
Daskalogianni
C
,
Fahraeus
R
. 
Pioneer translation products as an alternative source for MHC-I antigenic peptides
.
Mol Immunol
2015
;
68
:
68
71
.
39.
Apcher
S
,
Daskalogianni
C
,
Lejeune
F
,
Manoury
B
,
Imhoos
G
,
Heslop
L
, et al
Major source of antigenic peptides for the MHC class I pathway is produced during the pioneer round of mRNA translation
.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA
2011
;
108
:
11572
7
.
40.
Durand
S
,
Lykke-Andersen
J
. 
Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay occurs during eIF4F-dependent translation in human cells
.
Nat Struct Mol Biol
2013
;
20
:
702
9
.
41.
Williams
DS
,
Bird
MJ
,
Jorissen
RN
,
Yu
YL
,
Walker
F
,
Zhang
HH
, et al
Nonsense mediated decay resistant mutations are a source of expressed mutant proteins in colon cancer cell lines with microsatellite instability
.
PloS One
2010
;
5
:
e16012
.
42.
de Klerk
E
,
t Hoen
PA
. 
Alternative mRNA transcription, processing, and translation: insights from RNA sequencing
.
Trends Genet
2015
;
31
:
128
39
.
43.
Yewdell
JW
,
Nicchitta
CV
. 
The DRiP hypothesis decennial: support, controversy, refinement and extension
.
Trends Immunol
2006
;
27
:
368
73
.
44.
Yewdell
JW
,
David
A
. 
Nuclear translation for immunosurveillance
.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA
2013
;
110
:
17612
3
.